About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



39 Emory L. J. 697 (1990)
Procreative Liberty and Human Genetics

handle is hein.journals/emlj39 and id is 711 raw text is: PROCREATIVE LIBERTY AND HUMAN GENETICS
John A. Robertson*
Modern human genetics has generated considerable information about
the genetic basis of disease and illness.' This information is helpful in
diagnosis and often in treatment. It may also encourage behavior that will
lessen the expression of genetically-based disease.
Genetic knowledge, however, is likely to have its greatest impact on
reproductive decisionmaking. Through at-risk or population screening,
persons will be able to learn their carrier status for heterozygote genetic
diseases, and avoid conception of offspring with undesirable genetic traits.
Prenatal, and eventually even preimplantation, diagnosis of embryos and
fetuses will permit women to avoid carrying such offspring to term. As
new carrier and prenatal tests emerge, genetic selection of offspring char-
acteristics will become increasingly routine.
The use of genetic information to make reproductive choices raises a
number of ethical, legal, and social issues that need close attention.' Be-
cause the genetic knowledge at issue is relevant to individual or marital
choices about reproduction, these issues may be usefully viewed through
the lens of procreative liberty. Does a couple's right to reproduce or avoid
reproduction give them a right of access to this information? May deci-
sions to conceive or continue a pregnancy be made on genetic grounds?
Must couples learn their carrier status? Must they act on this
information?
While these questions apply to a wide range of genetic conditions, it is
helpful to focus discussion on one disease and follow these issues through
several stages of relevance. This Article will focus on cystic fibrosis, be-
cause of its greater prevalence, rather than on the usual examples of sickle
* Thomas Watt Gregory Professor of Law, University of Texas at Austin School of Law.
S. ELIAS & G. ANNAS, REPRODUCrIVE GENETICS AND THE LAW (1987).
Despite their current prevalence, carrier detection and prenatal screening programs have
aroused ambivalence and even opposition. While much of the opposition has arisen from abortion of
genetically affected fetuses, there is also opposition to the deliberate use of genetic factors in reproduc-
tive decisionmaking. It implies that the worth of people - of mates and of offspring - depends on
their genetic makeup, not their intrinsic worth. The notion of manipulating, choosing or engineering
offspring characteristics might also be viewed as violating basic notions of the natural order, a human
interference with nature which can only go awry.