About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



34 J. Air L. & Com. 417 (1968)
The Attorney's Role in Accident Investigation

handle is hein.journals/jalc34 and id is 431 raw text is: THE ATTORNEY'S ROLE IN ACCIDENT INVESTIGATION
By ROBERT REED GRAYt
I. INTRODUCTION
T HE QUESTION of the attorney's role in aircraft accident investiga-
tion is a novel one. This puts me in an enviable position since I trust
none of you will be able to cite any authorities to contradict me. It also
means that my printed paper will contain no footnotes. I hope, however,
that these remarks will provoke thought and discussion, and that the dis-
cussion will provide footnote material for those who may write on the sub-
ject in the future. Also, I hasten to add that my remarks are my own and
are not, to my knowledge, specifically supported by any group or organi-
zation.
II. THE POLICY IN ACCIDENT INVESTIGATION
As an initial matter, I wish to make it clear that it is my belief that the
role of an attorney in accident investigation-and I stress accident inves-
tigation rather than litigation-is to assist in the determination of probable
cause and not to establish fault. I am aware that this position may raise
cries of outrage from negligence counsel on behalf of plaintiffs and de-
fendants alike. But it seems to me that we must get straight at the outset
what the reason is for accident investigation. It is a governmental function
participated in by airline operators, various unions, aircraft manufacturers,
and the FAA, to determine what happened-not for the purpose of plac-
ing blame, but rather to prevent another accident from occurring.
In this connection you should be aware that the regulations of the Na-
tional Transportation Safety Board look specifically to this type of ap-
proach. Section 431.2 of the NTSB's regulations reads as follows:
Aircraft accident hearings are held by the Board as a part of the investigation
of accidents involving aircraft in order to determine the facts, conditions,
and circumstances relating to each accident and the probable cause thereof
and to ascertain measures which will best tend to prevent similar accidents in
the future. It is purely a fact-finding procedure, and there are no formal
pleadings or issues and no adverse parties. During the course of the hearing,
no objections to any matter will be entertained from any party to the
investigation or any other person. Aircraft accident hearings are not subject
to the provisions of sections 4, 5, 7, 8, or 10 of the Administrative Proce-
dure Act.
Note that the regulation states that hearings involving aviation accidents
are to determine probable cause and to ascertain measures to prevent
similar accidents in the future. It is also noteworthy that the regulation
states specifically that the procedure is strictly fact-finding, and there are
no adverse parties. In aid of this approach, Section 431.16(b) provides:
t Attorney at Law, Hale, Russell & Stentzel, Washington, D.C.