About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



17 Duq. L. Rev. 473 (1978-1979)
The Legal Status of Bilingual Education in America's Public Schools: Testing Ground for a Statutory and Constitutional Interpretation of Equal Protection

handle is hein.journals/duqu17 and id is 501 raw text is: Comment
The Legal Status of Bilingual Education in
America's Public Schools: Testing Ground for a
Statutory and Constitutional Interpretation of Equal
Protection
I. INTRODUCTION
Millions of ethnic minority students attending American public
schools must learn their lessons with the additional hardship of an
English language deficiency. Of the forty-nine million children com-
pelled to attend our nation's schools, approximately five million
speak a principal language other than English.' Congress recognized
the special educational needs of this large number of children by
passing the Bilingual Education Act.2 Since the Act's passage in
1968, funding for bilingual education programs3 has been available
to local school districts. A few states have also enacted statutes in
an attempt to ameliorate the hardship of the language barrier.'
Several courts have taken steps towards eradicating the policies
of linguistic exclusion in the public schools of the United States.5
These courts have acted pursuant to the Supreme Court's 1974 deci-
1. W. GRANT & C. LIND, DIGEST OF EDUCATIONAL STATISTICS: 1977-78, 1 (1978); Office of
Education, U.S. Dept. of HEW, Draft: Five Year Plan 1972-77: Bilingual Education Pro-
grams, app. B, Aug. 24, 1971. A 1967 study concluded that three out of the five million are
unable to acquire enough proficiency in English to benefit from daily classes. Hearings on
H.R. 9840 and H.R. 10224 Before the Gen. Subcommittee on Education of the House Com-
mittee on Education and Labor, 90th Cong., 1 Sess. 7 (1967) (hereinafter cited as 1967
Hearings). Given the difficulty in determining present estimates, it must be assumed that
these figures represent conservative assesments of the needs of the 1970's. See notes 13 and
14 and accompanying text infra.
2. 20 U.S.C. § 880b (1970). However, in five years this Act had reached only about two
percent of the nation's bilingual children. 119 CONG. REC. S18811 (daily ed. Oct. 9, 1973).
3. As used in this comment, bilingual programs of education can mean anything from
ESL (English as a second language) in the first grade to a full range of subjects over six or
more grades. Hearings on H.R. 15 Before the Subcomm. on Elementary, Secondary, and
Vocational Education of the House Comm. on Education and Labor, 95th Cong., 1st Sess.
178 (1977). Of course, the proper form of bilingual instruction to be implemented depends
upon community circumstances and the extent of the need for bilingual education within the
school system.
4. See notes 63 & 64 and accompanying text infra.
5. See notes 68-113 and accompanying text infra.