About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



22 Geo. J. Legal Ethics 811 (2009)
Who's Afraid of a Uniform Federal Court Bar: Dispelling Fears about Standardizing Admission and Regulation of Attorneys in Federal Courts

handle is hein.journals/geojlege22 and id is 817 raw text is: Who's Afraid of a Uniform Federal Court Bar?
Dispelling Fears About Standardizing Admission
and Regulation of Attorneys in Federal Courts
INGRID EPPERLY*
INTRODUCTION
Although the United States has an inidependent federal judiciary, Congress has
never established uniform federal rules for admission to the bars of the nation's
federal district and circuit courts of appeal.' Nor does there exist a uniform
federal code of conduct that attorneys in these courts must adhere to and by which
federal courts may discipline lawyers.' To fully understand the reasons for this
lack of uniformity, one must consider these two issues of federal bar admissions
and federal bar regulation together, for the lack of the former is arguably due to
the difficulty of implementing the latter. While the creation of a national federal
bar would be a conceivably easy task,3 the uniform regulation of such a bar's
members poses enormous challenges.4 Nevertheless, both uniform admissions
and regulation arenecessary, and the time has come to implement them.5
At issue in the debate over standardizing federal bar admission and regulation
are competing visions of the public interests at stake. Opponents of standardiza-
tion maintain that a uniform federal bar will prevent local districts from
safeguarding against the outside attorney who lacks adequate knowledge of local
practices and procedures, or who willfully chooses not to adhere to local ethical
rules.6 Proponents of standardization counter that the present regime of local
authority over the process creates costs for clients and attorneys and may impede
* J.D., Georgetown University Law Center (expected May 2010).
1. See, e.g., Trippe S. Fried, Licensing Lawyers in the Modem Economy, 31 CAMPBELL L. REv. 51, 59 (2008)
(noting that the concept of a 'federal bar' has been circulating among commentators since at least 1938 - the
ABA itself called for a uniform system of admission to federal courts in 1972 - but it has never come close to
implementation); Fred C. Zacharias, Federalizing Legal Ethics, 73 TEx. L. REv. 335, 356 (1994) (presenting a
synopsis of the historical support by prominent members of the legal community for the nationalization of
admission procedures in federal courts).
2. See, e.g., Zacharias, supra note 1, at 345 (assessing the need, over fifteen years ago, for uniform federal
rules due to (1) the nationalization of the practice of law; (2) the increase in multistate litigation and
transactions; (3) skewed client perceptions of lawyers' obligations as a result of splintered rules; and (4) the fact
that federal decisions and administration of regulations were already undermining state rules).
3. See id. at 404 (noting that [e]stablishing uniform admission requirements would not be difficult).
4. See discussion infra Part H.
5. See discussion infra Part Ill.
6. See, e.g., Judith A. McMorrow, The (F)Utility of Rules: Regulating Attorney Conduct in Federal Court
Practice, 58 SMU L.REv. 3, 9 (2005) (observing that state courts in particular with their strong and historical