About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



53 Emory L.J. 869 (2004)
The Pari Passu Clause in Sovereign Debt Instruments

handle is hein.journals/emlj53 and id is 881 raw text is: THE PARI PASSU CLAUSE IN SOVEREIGN DEBT
INSTRUMENTS'
Lee C. Buchheit*
Jeremiah S. Pam**
INTRODUCTION ................................................................................................ 871
I.   THE CLAUSE ......................................................................................... 871
A.      The Text ........................................................................................ 871
B.      The Context .................................................................................. 872
C.      The Sovereign Debt Enigma ......................................................... 874
II.    THE RATABLE PAYMENT INTERPRETATION ......................................... 877
A.      Tom, Dick, and Harry               in Brussels ................................................ 877
B.      Implications .................................................................................. 880
C.     Proliferation ................................................................................. 880
D.      Criticisms ..................................................................................... 883
III.    THE HUNT          FOR PARI PASSU .................................................................. 891
A.      Preferences and Priorities ........................................................... 892
B.      The Pari Passu Odyssey ................................................................ 894
1. Nineteenth and Early Twentieth Centuries: Pai
Passu     in Secured       Credits ........................................................ 894
2. Mid-Twentieth Century: Negative Pledge
in  Unsecured         Credits ............................................................. 897
3. Late Twentieth Century: Pari Passu and Negative
Pledge in       Unsecured         Credits ................................................. 900
Cleary, Gottlieb, Steen &      Hamilton acted as counsel to the Republic of Peru in the appeal of the
Brussels action referred to in note 16 of this Article, and is acting as counsel to the Republic of Nicaragua in
the action referred to in note 29 and to the Republic of Argentina in the actions referred to in notes 126-33. A
great many individuals have helped the authors in their hunt for pari passu over the last few years. Among
these are: Luis de Carlos Bertrdn, Frank G. Dawson, T. H. Donaldson, Marc Ellenbogen, G. Mitu Gulati,
Andrew Haldane, Catherine Hovaguimian, G. Hartwell Hylton, William Ledward, Robert P. McDonald, G.
Alfred Mudge, Charles E. Olson, John Orbell, Hugh S. Pigott, Ekaterina Y. Pischalnikova, Armando L.
Suratos, Michael R. Tomz, and Andrew Yianni. The authors also are grateful to the library of the Bank of
England, the ING Barings Archives, and the microfiche section of the Harvard Law Library for their generous
assistance in our research. The views expressed in this Article are those of the authors and should not be
ascribed to Cleary, Gottlieb, Steen & Hamilton or its clients.
* Partner, Cleary, Gottlieb, Steen & Hamilton (New York).
** Associate, Cleary, Gottlieb, Steen & Hamilton (New York).