About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



39 N.C.J. Int'l L. & Com. Reg. 1029 (2013-2014)
On the Effectiveness of Private Security Guards on Board Merchant Ships off the Coast of Somalia - Where Is the Piracy; What Are the Legal Ramifications

handle is hein.journals/ncjint39 and id is 1065 raw text is: On the Effectiveness of Private Security Guards on
Board Merchant Ships off the Coast of Somalia-
Where is the Piracy? What are the Legal
Ramifications?
Barry Hart Dubnerf & Claudia Pastoriusf
I.   Introduction: A Scenario   ................    ......1029
II.   Putting the State of Piracy off the Coast of Somalia into
Perspective  ....................       .............1031
III.  Significant Shifts in the International Guidance and
National Laws.............................1040
IV.   Important Legal Issues Raised When Employing
Security Guards Aboard Ships ..........        ........ 1044
V.    Human Rights Considerations on the Use of PCASP .....1051
VI.   Conclusion ........    .    ...............  ...... 1057
VII. Appendix          .................................1059
I. Introduction: A Scenario
You are part of a four-man private security team contracted to
protect a merchant vessel against piracy off the Somali coast,
spanning 1800 miles.' You see what appears to be a pirate
vessel. In this case, it is not a skiff. Most acts of piracy are
perpetrated using fishing skiffs that are modified to attack
t Professor of Law, Barry University, Dwayne 0. Andreas School of Law, Orlando,
Florida; J.D., New York Law School; LL.M., University of Miami, School of Law;
LL.M., New York University School of Law; J.S.D., New York University School of
Law.
tt J.D. Barry University, Dwayne 0. Andreas School of Law; B.A., Johns Hopkins
University.
I Robert I. Rotberg, Combating Maritime Piracy: A Policy Brief with
Recommendations for Action, WORLD PEACE FOUND. (WPF), Policy Brief #11, at 2 (Jan.
26, 2011).