About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



111 L. Q. Rev. 355 (1995)
Voyage Charters

handle is hein.journals/lqr111 and id is 377 raw text is: Reviews and Notices

Alain Wijffels is unimpressed with the concept of ius gentium as
expressed by civil law practitioners at the High Court of Admiralty
(lus Gentium in the Practice of the Court of Admiralty around
1600). Andrew Lewis argues that Roman law made a timely appear-
ance in England to help common lawyers understand their own law
( 'What Marcellus Says is Against You': Roman Law and Common
Law).
My principal complaint with this book is a small one. It is intended
as a festschrift for Peter Stein, but fastschrift would make a better des-
cription, because unfortunately the book stops short of reciting the
dedication. Perhaps this does not matter; if anyone misses the dedi-
cation, he will not fail to see the hand of Professor Stein in the work
itself.
E. P. METZGER.*
Voyage Charters. By JULIAN COOKE, JOHN D. KIMBALL, TIMOTHY
YOUNG, DAVID MARTOWSKI, ANDREW TAYLOR and LEROY
LAMBERT. [London: Lloyd's of London Press. 1993. xc + 929.
Hardback £135.]
THIS is a companion volume to the much older Time Charters, by Wil-
ford, Coghlin and Kimball, now already in its 3rd edition. Like Time
Charters it follows the technique of text with inset case summaries;
and contains commentaries both from the point of view of English
law and American law. Like Time Charters it is primarily a commen-
tary on a standard form, the 1976 Gencon form; again like Time
Charters it comments also on a second form, the Asbatankvoy form.
It also contains, however, in an appendix certain other forms. To
avoid overlap with other works it gives limited coverage on lay-time
and demurrage; on the other hand, and perhaps surprisingly, because
of the frequency with which bills of lading issued under charterparties
are subject to the Hague and Hague-Visby Rules it contains a sub-
stantial section on bills of lading and also a commentary on the Eng-
lish law relating to those Rules.
This is a considerably more substantial work than Time Charters.
Partly this is because there is much more to cover: time charters are a
more recent invention than voyage charters and the amount of cases
on them is limited. Indeed it was probably true to say that the earlier
book took into account all the cases on its topic, at any rate the Eng-
lish cases. No one could really hope to do that with voyage charters.
But also the writing team is larger, which obviously enables more in-
depth treatment; and the presence of members of the commercial Bar
on the team is perhaps the cause of much more extended treatment of
difficult theoretical matters, such as the conflict of laws, implied
terms, mistake and rectification, illegality, conditions precedent,
deviation, safe port, damages and the cancelling clause (to take
examples). The material on the Hague Rules is over and above.
* Brasenose College, Oxford.

APRIL 1995]