About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



40 Hous. L. Rev. 673 (2003-2004)
Eldred, the First Amendment, and Aggressive Copyright Claims

handle is hein.journals/hulr40 and id is 685 raw text is: ESSAY
ELDRED, THE FIRST AMENDMENT, AND
AGGRESSIVE COPYRIGHT CLAIMS
Alfred C. Yen*
TABLE OF CONTENTS
I.   INTRODUCTION     .................................................................... 673
II. CONVENTIONAL WISDOM AND AGGRESSIVE COPYRIGHT ..... 679
III. ELDRED AND THE FIRST AMENDMENT ................................. 682
IV. THE FIRST AMENDMENT AND THE ANALYSIS OF
AGGRESSIVE COPYRIGHT CLAIMS ........................................ 688
V. APPLYING THE FIRST AMENDMENT TO AN AGGRESSIVE
COPYRIGHT    CLAIM  ............................................................... 692
VI.  CONCLUSION    ....................................................................... 695
I. INTRODUCTION
In April of 1999, Zack Exley received a letter from a lawyer
representing    the   Governor     George    W. Bush      Presidential
Exploratory Committee. Among other things, the letter expressed
anger over Mr. Exley's Web site, which poked fun at Mr. Bush
*  Professor of Law, Boston College Law School. The Author would like to thank
the University of Houston Law Center for hosting the 2003 IPIL/Houston Santa Fe
Conference, the Houston Law Review for publishing the manuscripts, and Craig Joyce for
his effort in organizing the conference. Thanks are also owed to Joe Liu for comments on
an earlier draft, and to Sheila Bautista and Daniel Scales for their research assistance.

673