About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



55 Buff. L. Rev. 707 (2007-2008)
Separation of Religion and Law: Buddhism, Secularism and the Constitution of Bhutan

handle is hein.journals/buflr55 and id is 715 raw text is: Separation of Religion and Law?: Buddhism,
Secularism and the Constitution of Bhutan
RICHARD W. WHITECROSSt
As a legal anthropologist and a socio-legal researcher, I
was particularly interested to hear His Holiness discuss the
relationship between Buddhism and law. The study of law
and Buddhism is in its infancy, and there are difficult
questions to address. For example, we need to critically
evaluate what Buddhist law might be and what we are
attempting to achieve with the study of law and Buddhism.
And a related issue, of course, is what we mean by
Buddhism.
When I originally began to conceive my doctoral
research on law in the Buddhist state of Bhutan in the mid-
1990s, I wanted to examine the role of Buddhism in
contemporary   Bhutanese  law. Bhutan    is  the  last
independent Himalayan Buddhist state. Its political history
is separate from that of Tibet from the seventeenth century
onwards. Zhabdrung Ngawang Namgyal, who unified
Bhutan, implemented his personal vision of Bhutan as a
religious state, with secular and temporal rule combined
much more intimately than in the government of the Dalai
Lamas. Although British missions passed through Bhutan
to Tibet in the late eighteenth century and British colonial
forces defeated the Bhutanese in the 1860s, Bhutan was
never colonized and British influence was minimal. In
theory, Bhutan was a theocracy until the early twentieth
century, and the monarchy, established in     1907, is
descended from a major fifteenth century Bhutanese
Buddhist saint, Pema Lingpa.
During my fieldwork, I was fortunate to meet and
interview several major reincarnates in Bhutan; however,
they rarely discussed the relationship between law and
Buddhism, except perhaps to stress the importance of
t Honorary Fellow in Social Anthropology, University of Edinburgh. Associate
Member CNRS (Paris) UMR 8047.

707