About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



19 Annals Health L. 133 (2009-2010)
Hurricane Katrina and the Legal and Bioethical Implications of Involuntary Euthanasia as a Component of Disaster Management in Extreme Emergency Situations

handle is hein.journals/anohl19 and id is 139 raw text is: Hurricane Katrina and the Legal and Bioethical
Implications of Involuntary Euthanasia as a
Component of Disaster Management in
Extreme Emergency Situations
Fredericka K. Shea*
The delivery of health care in extreme disaster
situations presents the worst case scenarios and
places the most strain on our health care practitioners
and systems. This is apparent even to individuals
who are not involved in the delivery of health care.
Anyone with a television can recall the media
images of people jumping to their deaths and racing
from the collapsing Twin Towers in New York after
the terrorist attacks on September 11 th, as well as the
corpses floating through the water while panicked
individuals tried to signal passing helicopters from flooded rooftops after
Hurricane Katrina in New Orleans. Even as we live in the wake of these
events, we currently cope with the medical disaster involving the H1N1 flu
pandemic. Within the context of the delivery of medical care, the question
that inevitably arises during these events is should, or can, standards and
practices other than those which have been legally and ethically established
be applied given these extreme circumstances? The need to address this
issue is obvious given the reality that it will continue to be raised as we try
to cope with and plan for the medical fallout from future disasters.
One of the most compelling and ultimately troubling examples of an
alleged divergence from accepted legal and bioethical standards under
disaster circumstances arose out of the many allegations of euthanasia at
Memorial Medical Center (Memorial) in New Orleans against a physician
and two nurses during the Hurricane Katrina disaster. Dr. Anna Pou, a
respected head and neck surgeon, remained at the hospital throughout the
ordeal although she was initially given the opportunity to evacuate, and
treated the patients from Monday, August 29, 2005, until all remaining
living patients were evacuated on Thursday, September 1. Dr. Pou and
* B.A., Northwestern University; J.D., DePaul College of Law; LL.M., Loyola University
Chicago School of Law.