About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



14 Temp. Pol. & Civ. Rts. L. Rev. 609 (2004-2005)
Discussing a Taboo - A Review of Torture: A Collection

handle is hein.journals/tempcr14 and id is 615 raw text is: 







     DISCUSSING A TABOO-A REVIEW OF TORTURE: A
                                 COLLECTION



                             by JESSELYN RADACK*


     Balancing liberty and security in the new century calls for plumbing the grim
question of torture. Such an examination is long overdue. I was involved in the
first high-profile case of torture in the war on terrorism.        I am   the federal
whistleblower in the case of the so-called American Taliban, John Walker
Lindh.'
     In those first months following September 11 th, we didn't flinch at the famous
trophy photo of John Walker Lindh--one of the most prominent prisoners of the
Afghan war-naked, blindfolded, tied up and duct-taped to a board.2 That was our
first glimpse of nascent torture.' He was found barely alive, shot in the leg, and
suffering  from   dehydration, hypothermia, and frostbite.4       Despite his being
wounded, starving, freezing, and exhausted, U.S. soldiers blindfolded and
handcuffed him naked, scrawled shithead across the blindfold, and posed with
him  for pictures.5   Parts of his ordeal were captured on videotape.6          Sound


* Jesselyn Radack is an adjunct professor of law at American University's Washington College of Law
and serves on the D.C. Bar's Legal Ethics Committee.
    1. See, e.g., Juliette Kayyem, Prosecuting the War and Its Terrorists, N.Y. TIMES, July 16, 2002, at
A17 (The announcement yesterday that John Walker Lindh, the American Taliban, had pleaded
guilty to two counts of aiding our enemies can hardly be viewed as a victory for the Justice Department,
which had once claimed that the case against Mr. Lindh could put him in prison for life.); Fredrick
Kunkle, The Unexpected Prompts City to Alter Media Center Plans, WASH. POST, July 25, 2002, at T2
(First, Lindh--dubbed the American Taliban by some and simply The Rat by the New York Post-
took everyone by surprise by copping a plea July 15.); Michael Kilian, Lindh Pleads Guilty; American
Taliban Fighter Agrees to Serve 20 Years, CHICAGO TRIBUNE, July 16, 2002, at NI (In a surprise plea
bargain, American Taliban John Walker Lindh avoided a possible life sentence Monday by pleading
guilty to two counts of his original 10-count indictment: assisting the Taliban and being armed with
explosives.).
    2. To view the famous photo, see Michael Isikoff, The Lindh Case E-Mails, NEWSWEEK, June 24,
2002, at 8.
    3. See Richard A. Serrano, Prison Interrogators' Gloves Came Off Before Abu Ghraib, L.A.
TIMES, June 9, 2004, at Al (After American Taliban recruit John Walker Lindh was captured in
Afghanistan, the office of Defense Secretary Donald H. Rumsfeld instructed military intelligence
officers to 'take the gloves off' in interrogating him.).
    4. See FIONA DOHERTY ET. AL., A YEAR OF LOSS, HUMAN RIGHTS FIRST 195-96 (Michael
McClintock et al. eds., 2002), http://www.humanrightsfirst.org/us_law/loss/loss_ch4b.htm (last visited
Dec. 28, 2005) (On December 14, Lindh was diagnosed by Navy doctors as suffering from
dehydration, mild hypothermia and frostbite. Finally, on approximately December 15, Lindh received
surgery for his wounds, and the bullet in his leg was removed.).
    5. SEYMOUR M. HERSH, CHAIN OF COMMAND: THE ROAD FROM 9/11 TO ABU GHRAIB 37 (2004).
    6. See Government's Response to Defendant's Amendments Regarding Defendant's Subpoena
Request at 1 1, United States v. Lindh, 227 F. Supp. 2d 565 (E.D. Va. 2002), available at
http://news.findlaw.comhdocs/docs/lindh/uslindh52402grspnsub.pdf. The Government argued that: