About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



36 J.L. & Educ. 301 (2007)
Issue 3

handle is hein.journals/jle36 and id is 309 raw text is: An Empirical Study of Evolution, Creationism,
and Intelligent Design Instruction in Public
Schools
KRISTI L. BOWMAN *
ABSTRACT
Recent reports from students and teachers alike suggest that even
though teaching creationism as a credible scientific theory in public
schools is clearly unconstitutional, some teachers still do just that.
Conversely, despite the fact that many states' educational standards
explicitly require that evolution be taught, anecdotal evidence also sug-
gests that evolution sometimes is not discussed at all or, more frequent-
ly, may be the subject of mere cursory instruction. But, how widespread
are these practices? This Article reports and analyzes the results of a
2006 survey in which nearly 1,000 college students from across the
country provided their recollections about the frequency and manner of
evolution, creationism, and intelligent design instruction in their high
school science classes. In sum, about three out of ten recent public high
*Assistant Professor of Law, Michigan State University College of Law. J.D. Duke
University, M.A. Duke University, B.A. Drake University. Many colleagues provided ideas that
strengthened both the initial survey design and this manuscript. For their thoughtful comments at
various stages, I am grateful to: John Borkowski, Rachel Paine Caufield, Paul Gross, Gabrielle
Hann, Sonia Katyal, Christine Torgerson Marchand, William Marshall, Scott Moss, H. Jefferson
Powell, Frank Ravitch, Keith Summerville, Jay Wexler, Mark Weber, Sue Wright, and David
Zaring. The Article also benefited from presentation at the Drake University Center for
Humanities, Marquette University Law School, Michigan State University College of Law, and
the University of Mississippi School of Law. Additionally, the Drake University Center for the
Humanities funded the survey; Drake Law School provided summer research support; Shu-Ann
Fang tabulated data and calculated regression coefficients; Carolyn Gunkel and Adrienne Gross
provided superb research assistance, and Barbara Bean, Jane Edwards, Traci Goins, and Kathy
Prince provided helpful editorial assistance. Last but certainly not least, the survey would not
have reached the respondents without the assistance of the following Arts and Sciences faculty
across the country: Scott Cooper, Jay Demerath, Stan Guffey, Jennifer Metzler, Adam Hampton
Porter, Frank Rosenzweig, Douglas Rhodes, Kristen Ritchey, Jasmine Saros, Richard Saudargas,
Dan Spencer, Judy Stamps, Sara McFall Sullivan, Seth Tyler; and the following graduate stu-
dents: Katrina McLeod, Allyson Giles, and Christopher Collins.