About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



33 Judges J. 3 (1994)
Enforcing Visitation Rights: Innovative Programs in Five State Courts May Provide Answers to This Difficult Problem

handle is hein.journals/judgej33 and id is 51 raw text is: Enforcing
Visitation
Rights
Innovative programs
in five state courts
may provide answers
to this difficult problem
By Jessica Pearson
and Jean Anhalt
The   1984  Child  Support Enforcement
Amendments and the Family Support Act
(FSA) of 1988 vastly increased the attention
on child support and the financial well-being
of children. Less attention, however, is on
visitation, which many see as closely con-
nected to support issues. Noncustodial par-
ent groups have complained that visitation
interference is widespread (National Council
for Children's Rights, 1991) and that the in-
creasingly aggressive enforcement of child
support obligations has not been matched by
an equally aggressive enforcement of visi-
tation rights. Although interference with vis-
itation is not a legal defense to nonsupport

in most states, in practice many noncustodial
parents who believe they lack enforceable
access to their children may respond by
withholding support. Visitation interference
can reduce the contact between nonresident
parents and their children, thereby threaten-
ing postdivorce child adjustment and im-
pairing the psychological well-being of both
nonresident parents and their children.
In response to these contentions, Con-
gress urged state and local governments to
focus on the vital issues of child support,
child custody, and visitation rights. The
Family Support Act of 1988 (P.L. 100-485)
authorized state demonstration projects to
develop techniques to resolve child access
and visitation problems.'
It is not immediately apparent what type
of intervention is most appropriate to en-
force visitation rights. The most traditional
remedy-a court order prohibiting under
threat of contempt a parent from negatively
influencing the child-is very difficult to en-
force. One legal scholar lists the following
problems with such provisions:
Monitoring compliance ... is difficult
and distasteful given the need to interro-
gate the child; the requisite willful dis-
obedience is difficult to prove in face of
the order's vague commands; the con-
tempt procedure is itself cumbersome and
tine-consuming; and in the end, courts
frequently are loathe to punish the cus-
todial parent for contempt because of its
futility .... (Novinson, 1983:190).
Punitive approaches are also viewed with
disfavor because the punishment may affect
the children as well. Jailing, fines, or
changes of custody for parents are likely to
have strong and potentially damaging con-
sequences for children (Horowitz and Dod-

Polly Becker                                                                              Spring 1994

Spring 1 994

Polly Becker