About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



20 Isr. L. Rev. 282 (1985)
Alternatives to Withdrawl from an International Organization: The Case of the European Economic Community

handle is hein.journals/israel20 and id is 294 raw text is: ALTERNATIVES TO WITHDRAWAL FROM AN
INTERNATIONAL ORGANIZATION:
THE CASE OF THE EUROPEAN ECONOMIC COMMUNITY
Joseph H.H. Weiler *
I. The Reluctance to Talk About Divorce on the Wedding Day
The practice of omitting withdrawal clauses from the constituent treaties
of many international organizations was highlighted by Nathan Feinberg in
his article on Unilateral Withdrawal from an International Organization,1
acknowledged as ...the most thorough study of the subject.2 In a detailed
study of both State Practice and La Doctrine, Feinberg drew the conclusion
that there exists no presumption in favour of the right of unilateral
withdrawal, and that withdrawal is therefore permitted only if it is
expressly provided for or can be inferred by implication.3
This conclusion, which, it is submitted, has not been affected either by
the conclusion and entry into force of the Vienna Convention on the Law
of Treaties4 or by subsequent international practice,5 will serve as my point
of departure. Instead, however, of discussing international organizations in
general, I shall concentrate exclusively on the European Economic Com-
munity (EEC). The EEC defies precise conceptual categorization and
SB.A.; LL.B.; LL.M.; Ph.D.; Diplomate of the Hague Academy of Int'l Law; Professor
of Law, Michigan Law School, Ann Arbor. Director, European Policy Unit, Euro-
pean University Institute, Florence.
1 Published in the 1963 Volume of the Brit. Yrbk. Int'l L.; reprinted in N. Feinberg,
Studies in International Law (1979) 124 (Hereinafter, Studies).
2 Akehurst, Withdrawal from International Organisations (1979) 32 Current Legal
Problems 143. See also Hill, The European Economic Community: The Right of
Member State Withdrawal, (1982) 12 Int'l & Comp. L. 335.
3 Studies at 167.
4 See Akehurst, loc. cit.
5 The treaty establishing the Organization of Eastern Carribean States offers a
concrete example of a treaty both providing a right of withdrawal (Art. 24(2))
and concluded for an unlimited duration (Art. 24(1)). Arguing a-contrario one could
suggest that absenit such an explicit right to withdrawal it could not, with no other
supporting evidence, be inferred.