About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



24 Wm. & Mary L. Rev. 547 (1982-1983)
Water Rights Legislation in the East: A Program for Reform

handle is hein.journals/wmlr24 and id is 557 raw text is: WATER RIGHTS LEGISLATION IN THE EAST- A
PROGRAM FOR REFORM
RICHARD AUSNESS*
INTRODUCTION
Expanding municipal and industrial demand, along with increas-
ing use of supplemental irrigation,' have escalated consumptive
water use dramatically in the Eastern United States since World
War II.2 This escalated use already has caused water shortages m
some parts of the East, and experts predict more widespread water
supply problems in the future.3
As the inadequacies of the common law water rights system in a
water-scarce environment have become evident, many eastern
states have supplemented or replaced common law rules with some
form of statutory water allocation system. Typically, these statutes
establish a permit system administered by a state water resources
agency These permit systems generally have worked well, but
many of them have serious weaknesses. For example, water re-
sources planning frequently is not coordinated with administration
of the permit system. Additionally, most individual permits are of
relatively short duration, have no renewal guarantee, and leave
permit holders' rights uncertain during periods of water shortage.
Uncertainty for long-term planning and for water shortage periods
* Professor of Law, University of Kentucky. B.A. 1966, J.D. 1968, University of Florida;
LL.M. 1973, Yale University. The author wishes to thank the University of Kentucky Col-
lege of Law for supporting the writing of this Article with a summer research grant.
1. Irrigation is a highly consumptive use; more than two-thirds of the water applied to
crops generally is lost through evaporation or transpiration. In contrast, about 90% of the
water diverted for industrial or municipal purposes ultimately returns to the watercourse.
Marquis, Freeman & Heath, The Movement for New Water Rights Law in the Tennessee
Valley States, 23 TENN. L. REV. 797, 800 (1955).
2. See generally F Moss, THE WATER CRISIS (1967); J. WRIGHT, THE COMING WATER
FAMINE (1966); Maloney & Ausness, Administering State Water Resources: The Need for
Long-Range Planning, 73 W VA. L. REv. 209, 209-11 (1971).
3. According to one estimate, by the end of this century, only three of the 18 federally
designated water regions in the continental United States will be able to live comfortably
with their water supplies. Is U.S. Running Out of Water?, U.S. NEWS & WORLD REP., July
18, 1977, at 33.