About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



12 Wis. L. Rev. 313 (1936-1937)
Some Recent Proposals for Constitutional Amendment

handle is hein.journals/wlr12 and id is 327 raw text is: SOME RECENT PROPOSALS FOR CONSTITUTIONAL
AMENDMENT
JANE PERRY CLARK
The overwhelmingly important issue of the times is whether
power exists in government to meet and cope with the growth and
the concentration of economic power. Since the Supreme Court
weeded out the roots of federal authority in regard to the Railroad
Retirement Act, the N.I.R.A., the A.A.A., and the Guffey Coal Act,'
it has become clearly apparent that the federal government has no
power to control certain social and economic difficulties. Until the
effect of the New York minimum wage decision was changed and it
was decided that states do have power to enact minimum wage legis-
lation,2 states were also effectively prevented from certain types of
social and economic regulation. As a result, those who realize the
necessity for such control have come to believe that the Constitution
must be re-interpreted by .a liberal court in accordance with present-
day needs, or must be amended to make it more clearly responsive
to those needs. Those who advocate the reinterpretation theory main-
tain that a narrow view is a perversion of the intention of the fathers,
who were in favor of a broad national power to act for the general
welfare of the people. All that is necessary, in this view, is to return
to the concept of the fathers.3 Those who disagree with this insist
that even if the courts, by one means or another, are persuaded to use
judicial self-restraint in interpretation of the Constitution, neverthe-
less, courts are always subject to the winds of political change and
new uncertainties may always be substituted for present ones. The
advocates of constitutional amendment furthermore see the necessity
for clearer definition of the functions and responsibilities of govern-
ment than is provided by the present constitutional phraseology.
1 Railroad Retirement Board v. Alton Ry. Co., 295 U. S. 330, 55 Sup. Ct. 8
(1935) ; A.L.A. Schechter Poultry Corp. v. United States, 295 U. S. 495, 55
Sup. Ct. 837 (1935); United States v. Butler, 297 U. S. 1, 56 Sup. Ct. 312
(1936) ; Carter v. Carter Coal Co., 298 U. S. 238, 56 Sup. Ct. 855 (1936).
2Morehead, Warden v. Tipaldo, 298 U. S. 587, 56 Sup. Ct. 918 (1936); West
Coast Hotel Co. v. Parrish, 57 Sup. Ct. 578 (1937) (in substance overruling the
holding of unconstitutionality in the Tipaldo case).
'Cf., for example, Corwin, The Commerce Power versus States Rights (1936)
passim; Brant, Storm Over the Constitution (1936) passim; Wallace, Whose Con-
stitution (1936) passim; Beard, The Kind of a Constitution Its Makers In-
tended, Roosevelt Record, April 25, 1936, p. 3. et. seq.; Acheson, Address before
Maryland State Bar Association, Atlantic City, N. J. July 4, 1936; Corwin,
President and Court, a Crucial Issue, N. Y. Times Magazine, Feb. 14, 1937.