About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



43 Vand. L. Rev. 529 (1990)
Life-Without-Parole: An Alternative to Death Or Not Much of a Life at All

handle is hein.journals/vanlr43 and id is 543 raw text is: Life-Without-Parole: An Alternative
to Death or Not Much of a Life at
All?
I.  INTRODUCTION  ......................................  530
II. THE DEVELOPMENT OF PRECEDENT FOR LIFE-WITHOUT-PA-
ROLE  ..............................................  534
A. Constitutionality in Federal Courts .............  534
1.   Schick  v. Reed  ...........................  534
2.   Subsequent Cases  ........................   535
B. Application in State Courts ....................   538
III. DIFFERING VERSIONS OF LIFE-WITHOUT-PAROLE AND THEIR
USE  BY  THE  STATES  .................................  540
A.   Triple Tiered Approach ........................  541
B.   Triple Tiered Approach with a Set Minimum of
Y ears  .........................................  542
C. Double Tiered Approach .......................     543
D. Double Tiered Approach with Varying Terms of
Y ears  .........................................  545
E. Double Tiered Approach Without a Death Penalty     546
F.  Single Tiered Approach ........................   547
IV. SPECIFIC APPLICATION AND EXPERIENCE IN Two STATES..   547
A. Alabama's Double Tiered Approach .............     548
B. Kentucky's Triple or Quadruple Tiered Approach     551
V. BENEFITS, PROBLEMS, AND FUTURE IMPLICATIONS OF LIFE-
W ITHOUT-PAROLE  ...................................  554
A. Potential Benefits of Life-Without-Parole ........  556
1.   A Surer Penalty in Many Cases ............  556
2.   The Preservation of Human Life? .........    557
3.   An Additional Prosecutorial Tool in Murder
T rials  ...................................  559
B. Problems with the Current Applications of Life-
W ithout-Parole  ................................  559
1.   Relatively Little Use of the Sanction in Capi-
tal  Cases .................................  559
2.   A Lack of Information in General ..........  560
C.  Future Implications ............................  561