About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



15 Stan. L. & Pol'y Rev. 579 (2004)
Linguistic Profiling and the Law

handle is hein.journals/stanlp15 and id is 585 raw text is: LINGUISTIC PROFILING AND THE LAW
Dawn L. Smalls*
I. INTRODUCTION
Linguistic profiling is a term used to describe inferences that are often
made about a person's speech. Inferences may include where a speaker is from,
whether he/she is male or female, or whether he/she is native born to the United
States. These   judgments    reflect  learned  speech   characteristics  that
communicate much of this information. However, this process can be used for
discriminatory purposes and to the detriment of language and racial minorities.
This Note seeks to document the occurrence of linguistic profiling in the
law. This includes an examination of its use in employment discrimination,
housing discrimination, and finally the criminal law.
II. GENERALLY
Linguistic profiling is a term that has recently been coined to represent the
auditory equivalent of'racial profiling.'
Whereas 'racial profiling is based on visual cues that result in the
confirmation or speculation of the racial background of an individual, or
individuals, linguistic profiling is based upon auditory cues that may include
racial identification, but which can also be used to identify other linguistic
subgroups within a given speech community.
Linguists confirm this proposition. A study by Purnell, Isardi, and Baugh
preliminarily indicates that (a) dialect-based discrimination takes place, (b)
* Associate, Boies, Schiller & Flexner; B.A. in Linguistics, Boston University; J.D. Stanford
Law School.
This note is the product of a collaboration with Professor John Baugh and the American
Linguistic Heritage Survey. I would like to thank Professor Baugh for introducing me to this
issue and for being a great friend and mentor throughout the development of this note. I
would also like to thank George Fisher for serving as my advisor for this project and for
taking the time to offer many thoughtful and insightful comments, all of which I found
incredibly helpful.
1 John Baugh, Linguistic Profiling, in BLACK LINGUISTICS: LANGUAGE, SOCIETY, AND
POLITICS IN AFRICA AND THE AMERICAS 155, 155-63 (Sinfree Makoni et al. eds., 2003).
21d. at 158.