About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



101 N.C. L. Rev. 787 (2022-2023)
Beyond Legal Deserts: Access to Counsel for Immigrants Facing Removal

handle is hein.journals/nclr101 and id is 790 raw text is: 


101 N.C. L. REV. 787 (2023)


BEYOND LEGAL DESERTS: ACCESS TO COUNSEL
          FOR IMMIGRANTS FACING REMOVAL

                      EMILY   RYO  &  REED  HUMPHREY

   Removal proceedings are high-stakes adversarial proceedings in which
   immigration  judges must  decide whether to allow immigrants  who  allegedly
   have  violated U.S. immigration laws  to stay in the United States or to order
   them  deported to their countries of origin. In these proceedings, the government
   trial attorneys prosecute noncitizens who often lack English fluency, economic
   resources, and familiarity with  our legal system. Yet, most immigrants  in
   removal  proceedings do not have legal representation, as removal is considered
   to be a  civil matter and courts have not recognized a right to government-
   appointed counselfor immigrants facing removal. Advocates, policymakers, and
   scholars have   described this situation as an  access-to-justice crisis or a
   representation crisis for immigrant communities. The prevailing wisdom suggests
   that the solution to this crisis is more lawyers or more nonlawyer practitioners,
   such  as accredited representatives and legal technicians, who  can provide
   affordable and  quality legal services. The focus, therefore, has been on the
   ubiquity of legal deserts, commonly defined as areas that are in shortage of
   lawyers, and  on ways  to increase the supply of legal service providers in the
   marketplace.


   This Article presents an empirical study of legal representation that unsettles this
   prevailing wisdom  by showing why an adequate supply of legal service providers
   is a necessary, but not a sufficient, condition to address the representation crisis.
   Our  study uses a new and original dataset that we compiled for the purposes of
   this study on immigration lawyers and non-detained immigrant  respondents in
   removal  proceedings. Our findings suggest that although the focus on the supply-
   side dimension of the representation crisis is important, it obscures other complex


     *  © 2023 Emily Ryo & Reed Humphrey.
     ** Professor of Law and Sociology, University of Southern California Gould School of Law.
This research was supported by the ABF/JPB Foundation Access to Justice Fellowship to the first
author. The statements made and views expressed are solely the responsibility of the authors. We are
grateful to Alejandra Chaisson, Zach Hollo, Paul Moorman, Helena de Oliveira Laub, Joshua
Rodriguez, Karen Skinner, and Daniel Tsai for their invaluable research support. Our data collection
on immigration lawyers would not have been possible without the assistance of Tizita Wasihun at the
American Immigration Lawyers Association. We thank Irene Bloemraad, Ingrid Eagly, Nancy Foner,
Fatma Marouf, Ian Peacock, Jaya Ramji-Nogales, Andrew Schoenholtz, Juliet Stumpf, Lauren Sudeall,
and Jeffrey Wasserman for their helpful comments and insights on earlier drafts. Direct all
correspondence to Emily Ryo, USC Gould School of Law, 699 Exposition Blvd., Los Angeles, CA
90089. Email: eryo@law.usc.edu.
    *** Ph.D. Candidate, Evans School of Public Policy and Governance, University of Washington.