About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



61 Baylor L. Rev. 818 (2009)
The Court Says No To Incorporation Rebound: Virginia v. Moore

handle is hein.journals/baylr61 and id is 824 raw text is: THE COURT SAYS No To INCORPORATION REBOUND

VIRGINIA V. MOORE
Morris B. Hoffman*
I.      Introduction   ............................................................................ 819
II.     Virginia   v. M oore ................................................................... 820
III.    A  Brief History of Incorporation ........................................... 824
IV.     Incorporation Rebound .......................................................... 833
V.      The Supreme Court's Limited Jurisprudence on
Incorporation Rebound in a Criminal Context ....................... 838
A. The Probable Cause Core of the Search and Seizure
C lau se  .............................................................................. 838
B. The Supervisory Cases .................................................... 840
C. Non-Supervisory Rebound Cases Dealing with
Searches Incident to Arrest ............................................. 844
VI.     A Brief History of Probable Cause to Arrest, the Arrest
Power and the Search Incident to Arrest ................................ 846
A. Why History Matters ....................................................... 846
B .  Probable    C ause ................................................................ 850
C.   The Arrest Authority ....................................................... 853
D. Searches Incident to Arrest ............................................. 858
VII.    Moore as a Positive Rebound Case ........................................ 862
A. Claim 1: The Slippery Slope from Positive to Negative
R ebound    .......................................................................... 864
B. Claim     2: The Need for Uniformity .................................. 865
* District Judge, Second Judicial District (Denver), State of Colorado; Adjunct Professor of
Law, University of Colorado. The views expressed in this article do not necessarily reflect the
views of the Second Judicial District or any of my colleagues on that Court. I thank Nestor
Davidson, Martin Katz, Robert Nagel and George Thomas for their helpful comments on earlier
drafts, and my former law clerk, Rachel Ollar, and two former interns, Ryan Thomas and Daniel
Chapman, for their research and editorial help.