About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



10 Acta Univ. Sapientiae: Legal Stud. 271 (2021)
The Openness of Civil Court Proceedings in the Time of the COVID-19 Pandemic

handle is hein.journals/ausapls10 and id is 272 raw text is: ACTA UNIV. SAPIENTIAE, LEGAL STUDIES, 10, 2 (2021) 271-285

DOI: 10.47745/AUSLEG.2021.10.2.08
The Openness of Civil Court Proceedings in the
Time of the COVID-19 Pandemic
Tomasz TOMCZAK
University of Opole (Poland)
e-mail: tomasz.tomczak@uni.opole.pl
Abstract. The COVID-19 pandemic has resulted in the adoption of several
measures to protect public health during civil trials in Poland. Some of these
measures have restricted the traditionally open nature of the trial by allowing
for closed hearings to be held in situations not regulated before. This
study examines such situations in the light of international human rights
instruments, from the dual perspectives of internal (between the parties) and
external (towards third parties) openness of court hearings. It is established
that such hearings do not contravene international human rights instruments
pertaining to a fair trial if the restrictions are well-founded and proportional,
even though some measures have to be taken in order to protect parties and
third parties vulnerable to the lack of the necessary instruments or technical
knowledge to attend hearings remotely. The author concludes that some
restrictions to open court civil proceedings during the COVID-19 pandemic
are likely to remain in place, and the possibilities of remote access may even
prove beneficial in enhancing the principle of the open trial.
Keywords: COVID-19, fair trial, public hearing, open court, Poland
1. Introduction
Before February 2020, probably nobody in Poland and in many other
jurisdictions thought that such a basic procedural principle as the openness of
court proceedings may be widely restricted. However, the COVID-19 pandemic
arrived, and even such a bedrock rule had to be rethought and adjusted to the
new pandemic reality. Due to the hazard to life and health, special measures have
been adopted to limit or exclude the open court principle. The aim of this article
is to critically consider those measures.
To attain this goal, the paper is structured as follows. Firstly, the importance
of the open court principle is presented. Part 3 elaborates on the measures
introduced, and the analysis is divided into the modification in reference to the
internal openness (part 3.1) and the external openness (part 3.2). Furthermore, the