About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



92 Phil. L.J. 518 (2019)
Karangalan: A Theoretical Foundation for the Filipino Conception of Human Dignity

handle is hein.journals/philplj92 and id is 547 raw text is: 







   KARANGALAN: A THEORETICAL FOUNDATION FOR THE
         FILIPINO CONCEPTION OF HUMAN DIGNITY*

                             Justin D.J. Sucgang


                                PROLOGUE

        Human dignity   has emerged   as the single most widely recognized
and invoked  basis for grounding the idea of human rights generally.1 Shaped
by the horrors of the Second  World  War, it has become  a potent instrument
in political and legal discourse, especially in the field of human rights. In fact,
because  of its perceived universality, the concept of human dignity serves as
a common curngy  of judicial decisions in matters of human rights.2

        However,   one should not be quick to conclude that human  dignity is
a universal concept. As Christopher  McCrudden observes, its   universality is
more  apparent than real. The recognition of human  dignity as a fundamental
principle seems  to camouflage   [its] use in human  rights adjudication to
incorporate significantly different theoretical conceptions of [its] meaning and
implications, enabling  the incorporation  of  just the type  of ideological,
religious, and cultural differences that a common   theory of  human   rights
would  need to transcend.3 McCrudden   further posits that:

        [B]y its very openness and non-specificity, by its manipulability, by
        its appearance of universality disguising the extent to which cultural
        context is determining its meaning, dignity has enabled East and
        West, capitalist and non-capitalist, religious and anti-religious to
        agree (at least superficially) on a common concept.4


        Cite as Justin Sucgang, Karangalan: A Theoretical Foundation for the Filipino Conception of
Human Dignity, 92 PHIL. L.J. 518, [Pincite] (2019).
        ** Lecturer, De La Salle University College of Law. LL.M.; Sen. William Fulbraht
Scholar, Clyde DeWitt Fellow, University of Michigan Law School; Juris Doctor, Salutatorian, De
La Salle University College of Law (2014); A.B. Psychology, magna cum laude, De La Salle
University (2009); Hughes Scholar, CSEAS Library and Special Collections Fellow, University of
Michigan Center for Southeast Asian Studies.
        1 Paolo Carozza, Human  Dignity in Constitutional Adjudication, in RESEARCH
HANDBOOKIN   COMPARATIVE CONSTITUTIONAL  LAW 459 (Tom Ginsburg & Rosalind Dixon
eds., 2011).
        2 Paolo Carozza, Human Dignity and Judiial Intepretation of Human Rights: A Reply,
19 EUR. J. INT'L L. 931-44 (2008) [hereinafter Carroza, A Reply].
        3 Christopher McCrudden, Human Dignity and Judiial Intepretation of Human Rights,
19 EUR. J. INT'L L.710 (2008).
        4 Id.


518