About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



46 Case W. Res. J. Int'l L. 433 (2013-2014)
Why Now Is the Time to Resolve the Dokdo/Takeshima Dispute

handle is hein.journals/cwrint46 and id is 439 raw text is: 

CASE W TERN RESERVE JouRNAL OF INTERNATIONAL LAW. VOL. 46- 2013


WHY Now Is THE TIME TO RESOLVE

    THE DOKDO/TAKESHIMA DISPUTE


                         Garret Bowmai

         Since the second half of the twentieth century, the Republic
     of  Korea    and  Japan   have   been   feuding  over   the
     Dokdo/Takeshima islets, a pair of small rocky landmasses
     located in the East Sea/Sea of Japan. Resulting from a rise of
     nationalism and the influence of historical identity politics,
     tension over the Dokdo/Takeshima islets is undermining an
     otherwise prosperous relationship between Korea and Japan.
     Given Korea's de facto control over the Dokdo/Takeshima islets
     and   Japan's  questionable  claim  to   sovereignty under
     international law, this Note advocates Japan's acknowledgment
     of  Korean   sovereignty.  Korean- politicians  must   also
     acknowledge the danger posed by pandering to nationalist
     populism and seek to create arbitration mechanisms for a
     peaceful resolution between the countries. This Note will
     conclude  that resolving the  Dokdo/Takeshima   controversy
     presents a unique opportunity to begin unwinding the political
     tensions that threaten Northeast Asia's productive economic
     interdependence.

                            CONTENTS
1.   INTRODUCTION ......................................................................... 434
II.  B ACKGROUND ............................................................................. 438
     A . H istorical  Context  ........................................................................ 438
     B. UNCLOS:  The Law of the  Sea ...................................................... 441
III. PROBLEMS WITH THE STATUS QUO AND ICJ ADJUDICATION ........... 443
     A. The Rise of China and a Changing U.S. Role in the Region ............. 444
     B. The Adverse Effect of Korean Populism on Compromise and
        D e-E scalation  ............................................................................... 447
     C. Neither ICJ Jurisdiction nor Arbitration over the Sovereignty
        Issue  Is  F easible  ........................................................................... 449
IV. A COMPREHENSIVE APPROACH TOWARDS A TENABLE SOLUTION .... 451
     A. International Law  Favors Korean Sovereignty ................................. 451
     B. Korea and Japan's Strategic Considerations ................................... 454
     C. Beyond Sovereignty: Resolving Boundary and Resource Issues .......... 458
V .  C ONCLUSIO N  ............................................................................... 46 1


Managing Editor, Case Western Reserve Journal of International Law;
J.D. Candidate Case Western Reserve University School of Law
(expected 2014); B.A. Michigan State University.