About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



65 Buff. L. Rev. 657 (2017)
The Decline of the Lawyer-Politician

handle is hein.journals/buflr65 and id is 689 raw text is: 











BUFFALO LAW REVIEW


    VOLUME 65             AUGUST 2017              NUMBER 4


       The Decline of the Lawyer-Politician

                        NICK ROBINSONt

                        INTRODUCTION

     In  Democracy     in  America, Alexis      De   Tocqueville
famously noted, [s]carcely any political question arises in
the United States that is not resolved, sooner or later, into a
judicial  question.1   This   observation    about   the   close
interplay of the judicial and political branches in the United
States is almost certainly an over-generalization,2 but it also
captures a central feature of the U.S. system of government



t Robina Fellow at Yale Law School, Lecturer in Political Science at Yale
University, and affiliated Fellow at Harvard Law School's Center on the Legal
Profession. I would like to thank David Wilkins, Vic Khanna, Marc Galanter,
Rick Abel, Bob Kagan, Guido Calabresi, Susan Rose-Ackerman, Lawrence Lessig,
Richard Abel, David Mayhew, Heather Gerken, John Witt, Shauna Shames,
Alicia Bannon, Adam Lioz, Ben Schneer, William Hubbard, Robert Gordon,
Gordon Silverstein, Maya Sen, Nick Carnes, Douglas McDonald, Bryon Fong,
Derek Davis, and participants of a workshop at Harvard Law School's Center on
the Legal Profession for their feedback on this Article.
   1. ALEXIS DE TOCQUEVILLE, DEMOCRACY IN AMERICA 280 (Phillips Bradley ed.,
1945).
   2. JEB BARNES & THOMAS F. BURKE, How POLICY SHAPES POLITICS: RIGHTS,
COURTS, LITIGATION, AND THE STRUGGLE OVER INJURY COMPENSATION 1 (2015)
(citing to literature arguing that de Tocqueville may have been wrong that all
political disputes do not eventually become judicial ones in the U.S., but that the
observation does explain a significant portion of U.S. politics); Mark A. Graber,
Resolving Political Questions into Judicial Questions: Tocqueville's Thesis
Revisited, 21 CONST. COMMENT. 485, 487 (2004) (arguing that most national
political questions that existed when de Tocqueville was writing during the
Jacksonian era were not, in fact, resolved into judicial questions).


657