About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



4 Loy. U. L. A. L. Rev. 408 (1971)
Accelerated Induction--The End of the Old Fast Shuffle: Gutknecht v. United States

handle is hein.journals/lla4 and id is 418 raw text is: ACCELERATED INDUCTION-THE END OF THE
OLD FAST SHUFFLE:
GUTKNECHT v. UNITED STATES1
David Earl Gutknecht at the time he refused induction into the armed
forces was just another young person among a growing number who have
registered disenchantment with the present draft system in the United States.
He has since played a major role in upsetting the Selective Service System's
ability to exercise a broad, roving authority, a type of administrative ab-
solutism not congenial to our law-making traditions.2
Gutknecht registered with his local board and was classified I-A. After he
notified the local board of his student status, he was reclassified II-S. Over
a year later he informed the board that he was no longer a student and was re-
classified I-A. He also asked for an exemption as a conscientious objec-
tor. When this request was denied, his I-A classification was reaffirmed.
On October 16, 1967, during the appeal of that classification, Gutknecht,
in an expression of opposition to the Vietnam War, turned in his notice of
classification and registration certificate by leaving them on the steps of the
Federal Building in Minneapolis.3 His appeal was denied on November 22,
1967, and five days later he was again notified of his I-A status. On De-
cember 20, 1967, Gutknecht was declared delinquent by his local board
pursuant to the Selective Service Regulations4 for failure to comply with
duties imposed by the Military Selective Service Act.5 On December 26, only
six days later, he was ordered to report for induction. As a result of the
declaration of delinquency, Gutknecht's induction had been accelerated.
Gutknecht appeared at the induction center when scheduled, but refused
to take part in the processing. Subsequently he was indicted and prosecuted
under the Selective Service Act.7 Gutknecht, tried without a jury, was found
guilty of wilfully and knowingly failing and neglecting 'to perform a duty
required of him' under the Act. He was sentenced to four years in pris-
1 396 U.S. 295 (1970).
2 Id. at 306.
3 Id. at 297.
4 32 C.F.R. § 1642.4 (1971).
5 50 U.S.C. § 462 (1964).
6 The Government conceded that it was unlikely that Gutknecht, at age 20, would
have been called at such an early date without the declaration of delinquency. 396 U.S.
at 317-18.
7 Section 12 of the Act calls for punishment by imprisonment for not more than five
years or a fine of not more than $10,000, or by both such fine and imprisonment,
....  50 U.S.C. App. § 462 (Supp. V, 1970).
8 396 U.S. at 297.