About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



18 Helsinki Monitor 125 (2007)
The Rise of Nationalism in Putin's Russia

handle is hein.journals/helsnk18 and id is 133 raw text is: The rise of nationalism in Putin's Russia

Alexander Verkhovsky'
The problem of political nationalism, especially radical nationalism, from the
very first moment of the collapse of the Soviet Union, became one of the most
discussed questions concerning Russia. A great deal was written on this topic;
nevertheless, the interest in the topic is still alive. On the other hand, political
life in Russia in the middle of this decade is so very different from the 1990s,
that the place and role of nationalism could not remain the same. That is why it
is impossible to limit oneself to what has been previously written.
First of all, it is important to explain that the question concerns Russian
ethnic nationalism and not any other form of nationalism. Of course there are
different forms of ethnic nationalism in Russia, but their peak occurred at the
start of the 1990s and ended a long time ago. They have totally exhausted their
mobilizing potential, since regional separatism has long ceased to be any kind
of real goal, and the mechanisms of autonomy have been learned and
'privatized' by regional elites, most of which are moderately ethnocratic. The
topic of cultural renaissance reached the 'defending' phase and is now more
linked to the notion of 'human rights of ethnic minorities' rather than with the
notion of 'ethno-nationalism'. In some of the regions of North Caucasus the
protest potential of ethno-nationalism was utilized by radical political Islam (it
was most visible in Chechnya, but similar processes are also occurring in some
other North Caucasus republics). But it was Russian ethno-nationalism that
grew significantly at the beginning of Putin's rule, and I will consider this form
of nationalism here.
It is also important to define briefly those changes in the ideology of
Russian nationalism between the periods of 'perestroika' and the second
presidential term of Vladimir Putin. In particular we are interested to what
extent Russian nationalism can be considered as a form of ethnic nationalism.
This question has always been problematic for Russian nationalists themselves
and for their critics. It is no coincidence that in the 1990s instead of the term
'Russian nationalists' the term 'national patriots' was used which allowed one
to emphasize the complicity of the attitude of Russian nationalism to the topics
of ethnicity and of imperialistic patriotism. The basic nationalistic slogan
'Russia for Russians!', i.e. the idea of the empire ruled by Russians, was very
controversial regarding what 'Russians' mean, where the empire's borders are
located and which social and political order is preferable for the empire.
Russian nationalism, when it was emerging from its semi-underground
Alexander Verkhovsky is Director of the SOyA Center for Information and Analysis
(http://sova-center.ru).