About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



39 Queen's L.J. 551 (2013-2014)
A Tale of Two Citizenships: Citizenship Revocation for Traitors and Terrorists

handle is hein.journals/queen39 and id is 565 raw text is: A Tale of Two Citizenships:
Citizenship Revocation for
Traitors and Terrorists
Craig Forcese
Amending Canada's citizenship laws to provide for denaturalization of traitors and
terrorists, as proposed by the current federal government, is an idea consumed with legal
flaws. To comply with international law on the prohibition of citizenship deprivation that
would result in statelessness, any such amendments would have to apply only to individuals
with dual citizenship. However, targeting those individuals would be very hard to defend
against equality-based challenges under the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms. In
addition, denaturalization of traitors and terrorists might well be perceived as a punitive
measure, whose impact and stigma would call for constitutional procedural protections far
stronger than those set out in the current Citizenship Act and the proposed revisions to it. Such
denaturalization also seems unlikely to advance any clear Canadian national security interest,
and would accomplish less than can be done through other laws, including the Criminal Code.
* LLM, Yale Law School; LLB, Faculty of Law, University of Ottawa; MA, Carleton
University; BA, McGill University; Associate Professor, University of Ottawa. Thank
you to Ani Mamikon, JD candidate, University of Ottawa, for her thorough research
assistance in preparing this article. Thank you also to the Law Foundation of Ontario
for the financial aid allowing me to acquire this research assistance. Last, thanks to the
anonymous peer reviewers for all their comments and suggestions. This article is stronger
as a result.

C. Forcese

551