About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



15 Hastings Int'l & Comp. L. Rev. 391 (1991-1992)
Neither Fish, Nor Flesh, Nor Good Red Herring Lok Adalats: An Experiment in Informal Dispute Resolution in India

handle is hein.journals/hasint15 and id is 405 raw text is: Neither Fish, Nor Flesh, Nor Good Red
Herring Lok Adalats: An Experiment
in Informal Dispute Resolution in India
By SARAH LEAH WHITSON*
The Indian legal system's most recent experiment in alternative dis-
pute resolution (ADR) has fallen short of its stated aims to indigenize
the formal legal system inherited from Britain and to extend legal protec-
tion to the poor. While the reasons for this failure are intricately tied to
its unique legal context, India's experience with ADR validates standard
critiques of similar Western experiments in informal justice.
The Indian Constitution calls on the national government to pro-
mote modern values of equality and non-discrimination. At the same
time, it directs the state to foster local government and judicial self-ad-
ministration consistent with traditional values and mores that often pro-
mote inequality and discrimination. This latter directive fueled
advocates of ADR, who criticized the formal legal system as adversarial,
procedurally inflexible, and inconsistent with a purported native prefer-
ence for informal local conciliation.
The Lok Adalats (the L.A. courts), literally people's courts, repre-
sent the latest attempt to reform the Indian legal system by emphasizing
informal justice. Administered through the legal aid program, the L.A.
courts were designed to provide speedy and informal resolution of dis-
putes through conciliation and mediation at the local level. Scholars,
judges, and the newly-developed legal aid bureaucracy promoted L.A.
courts as a popular innovation with tremendous promise to indigenize
legal proceedings.
However, many of these advocates expected the L.A. courts to en-
force equality and non-discrimination rather than local mores. Their
ambivalence towards local control and prejudices is reflected in the in-
creasing formalization of the L.A. courts. The L.A. courts became a hy-
* Associate, Cleary, Gottlieb, Steen & Hamilton, New York, N.Y.; J.D., Harvard Law
School, 1991; B.A., University of California, Berkeley, 1988. The author has recently partici-
pated in the Harvard Study Team's studies of the impact of the war on civilian casualties in
Iraq.