About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



27 Crim. Just. Rev. 301 (2002)
The Landrum-Griffin Act: A Case Study in the Possibilities and Problems in Anti-Union Corruption Law

handle is hein.journals/crmrev27 and id is 311 raw text is: Criminal Juvtice Review                             02002 College of Health and Human Sciences
Volume 27, Number 2, Autumn 2002                                  Georgia State University
THE LANDRUM-GRIFFIN ACT:
A CASE STUDY IN THE POSSIBILITIES
AND PROBLEMS IN ANTI-UNION
CORRUPTION LAW
David Witwer
The Landrum-Griffin Act (1959) emerged out of hearings held on union corruption by the U.S. Senate's Select
Committee on Improper Activities in the Labor or Management Field (1957-1959). The reform law reflected many
conflicting goals, including the desire of business groups to hamper new union organizing, but five of the act's seven
titles concermed union governance and reflected a belief that union corruption could be solved by fostering union
democracy. Though the act did bring some successes, it failed to protect democratic reform in the Teamsters Union.
one of its primary targets. The history of a reform group in Teamsters Local 282 in New York City highlights the
ability of corrupt incumbent officers with organized crime connections to circumvent the intentions of the law and
stifle dissent. The act's shortcomings have led the federal government to resort to the more intrusive, and therefore
more problematic, remedies provided by the RICO Act.
From 1957 to 1959, the U.S. Senate's Select Committee on Improper Activities
in the Labor or Management Field, better known as the McClellan Committee, held
hearings on the problem of labor corruption. The committee's work drew great
attention from the media, and news stories on the hearings depicted union
corruption as a widespread phenomenon. In these accounts, James Hoffa's
leadership of the Teamsters offered the most egregious example of union misrule
and the dangers that it presented for the nation's economy. Such revelations led to
calls for new legislation that would use the power of the federal government to
solve the problem. In 1959, Congress responded by passing the Landrum-Griffin
Act, more formally known as the Labor-Management Reporting and Disclosure Act
of 1959 (29 U.S.C. 401, et seq.) (1959).
Reflecting the range of groups that were involved in drafting and lobbying for the
bill, Landrum-Griffin attacked the phenomenon of corruption from a number of
different directions. Some provisions of the law stemmed as much from a desire
to weaken unions as from a desire to effect reform, because for some business
groups these constituted the same goal. Thus the law included new prohibitions
against union organizing tactics such as secondary boycotts and organizational
picketing. But Landrum-Griffin amounted to more than simply an attempt to
cripple labor's ability to organize. Five of the act's seven titles dealt specifically
with union governance. These provisions set standards for union officers and
guaranteed union members the right to informed decision making, in the hopes that