About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



26 Child & Fam. L. Q. 216 (2014)
Beyond the Balancing Scales: The Importance of Prejudice and Dialogue in a Local Authority v E and Others

handle is hein.journals/chilflq26 and id is 220 raw text is: 216

Case Commentary
Beyond the balancing scales: the
importance of prejudice and
dialogue in A Local Authority v E
and Others
Camillia Kong*
Keywords: Adjudication - anorexia - best interests - hermeneutics - Mental Capacity
Act 2005 - A Local Authority v E and Others
In May 2012, in A Local Authority v E and Others,' a best interests ruling was made
under the Mental Capacity Act 2005 to coercively treat a severely anorexic woman, E,
against her will. The best interests decision was purportedly reached through a
process of judicial balancing; however there is something deeply unsatisfactory about
this account. This commentary delves beyond the expressed balancing method and
applies the tools of philosophical hermeneutics to both understand and challenge the
best interests ruling in A Local Authority v E and Others. First, the hermeneutic
concept of 'prejudice' makes explicit the implicit judgments determining the best
interests decision in this case. Secondly the commentary challenges the best interests
decision in two ways: (1) the hermeneutic emphasis on dialogical understanding
provides grounds for questioning the judge's failure to integrate the views of E and her
wider decision community (including family and long-term clinicians); (2) the ruling
could be deemed invalid due to the implicit application of a status-based rather than
statutory functional test to assess E's current and retrospective capacity
INTRODUCTION
n May 2012 Jackson J ruled that a severely anorexic woman, E, was to be coercively
fed and treated against her wishes.2 Numerous factors make this decision
controversial. First, it directly opposed E's decision against treatment and desire to die
with dignity. Two advance decisions were made against tube feeding and life support,
yet both were overturned on the finding of retrospective incapacity Secondly, treatment
would involve extremely high risks, such as refeeding syndrome and E's susceptibility
to physical trauma due to osteoporosis. Mechanical ventilation might be required to
prevent her from dying during the course of treatment; and it was said that 'her
The Ethox Centre, University of Oxford. This commentary was written with the generous funding provided
by the British Academy under their Postdoctoral Fellowship Scheme, of which I am most grateful. My
thanks to two anonymous reviewers, Tom O'Shea, Jill Craigie, Charles Foster, Wayne Martin, and Fabian
Freyenhagen for their constructive comments on earlier drafts of this commentary.
[2012] EWHC 1639 (COP), [2012] COPLR 441.
2  Ibid.