About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



10 Acta Univ. Sapientiae: Legal Stud. 231 (2021)
In Technology We Trust? The Present and Possible Future of Private Enforcement

handle is hein.journals/ausapls10 and id is 233 raw text is: ACTA UNIV. SAPIENTIAE, LEGAL STUDIES, 10, 2 (2021) 231-244

DOI: 10.47745/AUSLEG.2021.10.2.05
In Technology We Trust? The Present and
Possible Future of Private Enforcement
Andras OSZTOVITS
PhD, University Professor
Kdroli GAspAr University of the Reformed Church in Hungary
e-mail: osztovits.andras@kre.hu
Abstract. In the course of this study, the author examines the current
and possible future implementations of advanced information and
communication technologies from the point of view of private enforcement
(adjudication) and specifically the way in which they may contribute to
reducing the time and resource requirements of the judiciary. Firstly, the major
challenges of the current judiciary are presented, including the overbearing
dogmatic approach to old principles of adjudication, resulting in a time-
consuming, costly, labyrinthine, and unpredictable procedure, opening the
way to private adjudication achieved via online platforms. In order for state
adjudication to survive, modern technologies must be employed to achieve
a data-based form of judicial process that is resource-efficient for the users of
this 'service', while also guaranteeing a fair trial (albeit by electronic means).
Such methods would include deployment of information and communication
technology tools to aid court-party and party-party communication,
using implementations of the blockchain to prevent evidence tampering,
renouncing paper-based procedures, and embracing AI-assisted adjudication.
Numerous examples of such solutions are provided, with some of their
risks also emphasized such as the 'black box' phenomenon applicable to AI
systems. The author concludes by stating that if private enforcement in the
form of judiciary is to survive, it must become competitive with the dispute
resolution options now being put forward by private actors.
Keywords: judiciary, new technologies, online dispute resolution platforms,
online courts, blockchain, artificial intelligence
1. Introduction
Societal expectations of justice vary in space and time. Yet, looking back over
the history of mankind, several constants emerge that have almost always been
present in the way courts operate: to reach a just (i.e. non-arbitrary) decision,
preferably as soon as possible. It is precisely the latter, the time factor, which