About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



16 Art Antiquity & L. 173 (2011)
Legal Aspects of the Mystification and Demystification of Cultural Property

handle is hein.journals/artniqul16 and id is 185 raw text is: 













          LEGAL ASPECTS OF THE MYSTIFICATION AND
          DEMYSTIFICATION OF CULTURAL PROPERTY

                                  Kurt Siehr*

                                  ABSTRACT

      Cultural property has long been mystified. Even today  some people
      are still convinced that national cultural property has to be returned
      to the state of origin if such property is located abroad. Such demands
      for return may be a good case for return stipulations, settlements and
      exchanges. But if there is no such agreement between the parties, law
      courts have to decide the dispute. Law courts have to decide the dispute
      according to law. They do not normally have any discretion to deviate
      from statutory provisions and fixed case law. What they can do is this.
      They demystify cultural property issues and distinguish between certain
      types of art works and cultural items, e.g. archaeological items, human
      remains and holocaust art. This they do according to national provisions
      and  according to international conventions or transnational law if
      implemented  by national legislation. There are, however, at least five
      limitations to a return claim: bonafide purchase, statute of limitations,
      laches, no enforceability of foreign exports prohibitions unless the
      enforceability is recognised between State parties to a convention, no
      retroactivity of law making in national law as well as in international
      law. If such limitations apply, parties may settle their claim or find
      another solution. In any case no State is obliged to recognise claims
      for the return of foreign cultural property unless such property has been
      stolen, smuggled, confiscated or looted and no limitation of such actions
      is given. If there are still unanswered problems, parties may rely on
      forthcoming conventions, statutes, principles, and codes of ethics and
      they may already today settle their case according to these guidelines.

           1. MYSTICAL  PAST:  SACRED  OBJECTS,  MYTHS   AND  IDOLS

Ancient texts narrate history and legends. Mankind's early epic works sing of heroic
and tragic events, which may possibly have an historical background but which are

      *     Professor Emeritus of the University of Ziirich/Switzerland Faculty of Law;
            Research Fellow at the Max-Planck-Institute for Comparative and International
            Private Law in Hamburg/Germany. Many thanks to my brother-in-law, Dr
            John F. Davis, for his translation into English. A German version of this paper
            was published inKunst undRecht 13 (2011): 87 - 108.


173