About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



83 Am. J. Int'l L. 318 (1989)
Agora: Downing of Iran Air Flight 655

handle is hein.journals/ajil83 and id is 326 raw text is: AGORA: THE DOWNING OF IRAN AIR FLIGHT 655
INTRODUCTION
How quickly one forgets. On Sunday, July 3, 1988, an Iran Air A300
Airbus, with 290 persons on board, was shot out of the sky by two surface-
to-air missiles launched from the U.S.S. Vincennes, a guided-missile cruiser
on duty with the United States Persian Gulf/Middle East Force. The first
reports from Washington were that the Vincennes had acted in self-defense
against hostile Iranian aircraft.' Some 12 hours later, the Pentagon admit-
ted that the Vincennes had made a mistake, that the aircraft it saw approach-
ing was a wide-bodied airliner on a regularly scheduled flight, not an F-14
Tomcat with hostile intent and capability.
There were, of course, tense times in the Persian Gulf in early July 1988.
Iraq had been conducting air strikes against Iranian oil facilities and ships,
Iranian F-14s (sold by the United States to the Iran of the Shah a decade
earlier) had retaliated, and small boats launched from Iran were challenging
ships approaching the Strait of Hormuz. No doubt every American ship's
captain in the Gulf remembered the episode a year earlier when an Iraqi
missile had-it was said, by mistake-blown a hole in the frigate U.S.S.
Stark, with the loss of 37 lives. Still, the shooting down of Iran Air Flight 655
was clearly a tragic error.
Within a few days, President Reagan announced his country's regrets,
and promised that the United States would make an exgratia payment to the
families of the victims. Many persons in Congress and around the country
resented the notion of paying compensation to Iran, of all countries, and
doubted that such compensation would reach the families of the victims. As
of the end of the Reagan administration, no compensation had in fact
been paid.
What follows is,first, the official summary of the incident prepared for the
Journal by the Office of the Legal Adviser of the Department of State,
including the major portion of the congressional testimony of the Legal
Adviser; second, extended excerpts from the testimony of Professor Harold
G. Maier, formerly Counselor on International Law to the Office of the
Legal Adviser; third, the Findings and Conclusions of the investigation con-
ducted by a team of five international civil servants dispatched by the Inter-
national Civil Aviation Organization pursuant to a decision of that organiza-
tion's Council ofJuly 14, 1988; and fourth, some reflections by a member of
the Board of Editors long concerned with international aviation law.
'See N.Y. Times, July 4, 1988, at Al, col. 6, A4,col. 1; Wash. PostJuly4, 1988, at A 1, cols.
5-6.