About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



48 Denv. L.J. 211 (1971-1972)
Diversion from the Criminal Process: Informal Discretion, Motivation, and Formalization

handle is hein.journals/denlr48 and id is 223 raw text is: DIVERSION FROM THE CRIMINAL PROCESS:
INFORMAL DISCRETION, MOTIVATION, AND
FORMALIZATION
By SAMUEL J. BRAKEL*
CONTENTS
INTRODUCTION  ........................................  --------....................... . .   211
I.  T HE  D IVERSION  C ON CEPT  ----------------------------------------------------------------  213
II.  T HE  SPECIFIC  Focus                                     21................................ ............................ ....  214
III. SPECIFIC PRACTICES AND THEIR RATIONALES .................................. 216
A. W  hite Collar Crimes ...................................................... .  217
B .  S h o p lif tin g   .................... ..........................................................- 2 20
C .  F am ily  D isp u tes  .......................................................................  222
D .  F ir s t  O ffe n s e  ------------------------------------------------------------------------------  2 2 4
IV. FORMALIZING  DIVERSIONARY  PRACTICES  ......................................-227
A. Statutory Grace Periods and White Collar Crimes ........ 229
B. Restitution, Fines, and Shoplifting ............................... 231
C. Peace Bonds and Family Disputes .................................. 233
D. Deferred Sentences, Court Employment Programs,
a n d  F irst  O ffen ses  ...... .. .......   ................................................. 234
C ONCLUSION  ................. .. ................................ .............................  236
INTRODUCTION
T HE concept and practice of diversion is neither novel nor
esoteric. Indeed, the exercise of some forms of discretion
by criminal justice officials- ranging from the initial decision
not to arrest, to the determination to refrain from prosecution,
and up through the acquittal of the guilty-has always been
an integral part of the criminal process. However, recognition
and articulation of this phenomenon as part of a conceptually
distinct and analytically helpful process called diversion is much
more recent. Only in the past few years has the term diversion
become common usage not only in academic circles, but even
among officials in the criminal justice system who, having
*Research Attorney, American Bar Foundation; A.B. 1965, Davidson
College; J.D. 1968, University of Chicago Law School.
211