About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



38 Vand. L. Rev. 431 (1985)
Landlord Liability for Crimes Committed by Third Parties against Tenants on the Premises

handle is hein.journals/vanlr38 and id is 445 raw text is: Landlord Liability for Crimes Committed
by Third Parties Against Tenants on the
Premises
I.  INTRODUCTION  ..................................  432
II. THE LEGAL HISTORY: PROPERTY AND TORT PRINCI-
PLES THAT HAVE SHAPED THE LANDLORD'S RESPONSI-
BILITIES  ........................................  433
A.   Common-Law Origins of the Landlord-Tenant
Relationship  ..............................  433
B.   The Expansion of Landlord Liability in Tort  434
C.  The Expansion of Landlord Liability for
Crimes of Third Parties ....................  436
D. The Lease as Contract: Housing Codes ......    438
III. THE LIABILITY DECISIONS: TORT, WARRANTY OF HAB-
ITABILITY, OR  CONTRACT  .........................  440
A. Kline v. 1500 Massachusetts Avenue Apart-
ment Corp.: Tort  ..........................  440
B. Trentacost v. Brussel: Warranty of Habitabil-
ity  .......................................  442
C. Flood v. Wisconsin Real Estate Investment
Trust: Contract ............................  444
IV. THE EMERGING HYBRID SOLUTION ................     446
A. Development of a Liability Theory ..........   446
B. Duty: The Tort Theory Duty of Care .......     447
1.   Policy Justifications ...................  447
2.   Judicial Recognition ..................  448
3.   Bases of the Duty  ....................  451
(a)   Statutes  .......................  451
(b)   Contract: Express and Implied
Warranties of Security .........  452
4.   Scope of the Duty  ....................  454
(a)   The Landlord Is Not an Insurer
of Tenants' Safety .............  454
(b)   Foreseeability Based on Knowl-
edge of Prior Crimes ...........  454
C.  Causation  .................................  456
D .  Proposal ..................................  458