About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



13 Am. J.L. & Med. 233 (1987-1988)
Consciousness: The Most Critical Moral (Constitutional) Standard for Human Personhood

handle is hein.journals/amlmed13 and id is 235 raw text is: Consciousness: The Most Critical
Moral (Constitutional) Standard
For Human Personhood
Ronald E. Cranford, M.D.*
and David Randolph Smith, J.D.**
For the past two decades, the medical profession and society
have debated the definition of death. Some reasonable consensus
has been reached on this issue, in theory and in practice. In the last
few years, however, a far more important debate has been evolving
- the definition of human personhood. Human personhood has
been discussed extensively in the past with respect to the abortion
question and other issues concerning the beginning of life. More
recently, however, the definition of personhood has been raised
with respect to termination of treatment decisions at the end of life
and, in particular, on the appropriate care of patients in a persistent
vegetative state.
Our major premise is that consciousness is the most critical
moral, legal, and constitutional standard, not for human life itself,
but for human personhood. There is nothing highly original in our
approach to this particular issue; others have advanced similar argu-
ments in recent years.' Our position is somewhat unique as it is
derived more heavily from medical experience and medical reality.
We feel that once society fully understands the medical reality of
permanently unconscious patients and develops common sense
views based on this understanding, certain legal and moral positions
will follow logically. In our view, consciousness is the most impor-
tant characteristic that distinguishes humans from other forms of
animal life, going beyond the vegetative functions of heartbeat and
respiration. Thus, we believe that the permanent loss of all con-
*Associate Physcian in Neurology, Hennepin County Medical Center, Minneapolis,
Minnesota.
** Vanderbilt University School of Law, Nashville, Tennessee.
I See, e.g., Green & Wikler, Brain Death and Personal Identity, 9 PHIL. & PUB. AFF., 105, 105-
06 (1980); R. VEATCH, DEATH, DYING, AND THE BIOLOGICAL REVOLUTION: OUR LAST QUEST
FOR RESPONSIBILITY, 46-51 (1976); Youngner & Bartlett, Human Death and High Technology: The
Failure of Whole Brain Formulation, 99 ANNALS OF INTERNAL MED. 252-53 (1983).