About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



22 N.Y.U. Rev. L. & Soc. Change 371 (1996-1997)
Parent's Rights vs. Children's Interests: The Case of the Foster Child

handle is hein.journals/nyuls22 and id is 381 raw text is: PARENTS' RIGHTS VS. CHILDREN'S INTERESTS:
THE CASE OF THE FOSTER CHILD
MARSHA GARRISON*

Introduction  .........................................................
I. Parental Rights Termination in Context .....................
A. The Evolution of the Modem Foster Care System .......
B. The Child's Need for Permanence: A Newly Discovered
Problem Meets a Newly Available Solution ..............
II. Termination vs. Preservation of Parental Contact: Which
Serves Children's Interests? ..................................
A. Mechanisms for Ensuring Permanence: Adoption and Its
Alternatives ..............................................
B. Foster Care and Divorce: Are They Comparable? ......
C. Do Absent Parents Matter? .............................
III. Why Has Adoption Been Preferred to Alternatives That
Preserve the Parent-Child Relationship? .....................
A. Termination vs. Preservation of Parental Contact:
Practical Constraints and Confluent Adult Interests .....
B. The Cultural Symbolism of Adoption ....................
IV. Adoption's Symbolic Benefits: Their Hidden Costs .........
A. Overestimation of the Benefits of Foster Care
Alternatives ..............................................
B. Categorical Decisionmaking that Ignores Children's
N eeds ....................................................
C. Obscuring Benefits to the State Child Welfare System...
D. The Sacrifice of Children's Emotional Needs ............
Conclusion  ..........................................................

371
374
374
376
377
377
379
380
386
386
387
390
390
391
393
394
396

INTRODUCriON
In recent years, advocates for children have often asserted that paren-
tal rights conflict with children's interests. Deference to parental rights,
some have claimed, ensures that children are treated more like property
than people.'
* Professor of Law, Brooklyn Law School.
1. See, e.g., George H. Russ, Through the Eyes of a Child, Gregory K. A Child's
Right to Be Heard, 27 FAM. L.Q. 365, 388 (1993) (Children are literally 'repossessed' by
their biological parents in the same manner as though they were property, capable of own-
ership, without independent human rights of their own.). A number of academic commen-
tators have voiced similar concerns. See, e.g., ELIZABemT BARTHoLr, FAMiLy BoNms:
ADopnrioN AND HmF PoLnncs OF PARENTING 50 (1993 (discussing ways in which adoption
371

Imaged with the Permission of N.Y.U. Review of Law and Social Change