About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



34 U. Louisville J. Fam. L. 403 (1995-1996)
When is Parental Discipline Child Abuse - The Vagueness of Child Abuse Laws

handle is hein.journals/branlaj34 and id is 411 raw text is: WHEN IS PARENTAL DISCIPLINE CHILD ABUSE?-
THE VAGUENESS OF CHILD ABUSE LAWS
I. INTRODUCTION
A mother is grocery shopping with her unruly five-year-old child. In
an effort to control her child, the mother harshly spanks him three times.
In obvious shock and pain, the child begins to cry loudly. Of the other
shoppers who observed the incident, many would say that the child's
conduct justified the spanking while others would say hitting a child is never
the answer and is always reprehensible. Similarly, authorities who deal with
child abuse often differ in their opinions of what constitutes abuse.
Sometimes authorities have intervened in situations similar to the grocery
shopping incident and have charged the parent with child abuse.' However,
in other incidents in which the punishment has been more severe, other
authorities have determined that the parent acted within his or her legal
parental rights.2
Child abuse has become an increasingly apparent problem in this
country and is one of society's major concerns. According to the United
States Department of Health and Human Services, more than 918,000
children suffered abuse in 1992, including more than 212,000 cases of
physical abuse In response, legislatures and courts have acted in an
See In re W.P., 534 So. 2d 905 (Fla. Dist. Ct. App. 1988). Father slapped his child
on the face with an open hand when she used vulgar language toward her mother. The child
then pushed her father against a wall which caused the mother to pull the child's hair. Id.
Although the appellate court eventually found that the parents did not abuse the child, the
trial court had ordered protective service supervision and forced the parents to expend time
and money to defend the accusation. Id.
2 See Moakley v. State, 547 So. 2d 1246 (Fla. Dist. Ct. App. 1989). Father struck his
daughter on the buttocks and right hip with a leather belt which caused bruises. Id. at 1247.
Father requested that a Health and Rehabilitative Services counselor to take the child from
the home so that he would not hurt her. Id. The court recognized that this case was
borderline and held the evidence was insufficient to sustain a conviction for aggravated child
abuse. Id.
3 U.S. Bureau of the Census, StatisticalAbstract of the United States: 1994 (114th ed.)
Washington, DC, 1994, p. 213 No. 336, CHILD ABUSE AND NEGLECT CASES SUBSTANTIAT-