About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



23 J.L. & Pol'y 591 (2014-2015)
The Problematics of the Brown-Is-Originalist Project

handle is hein.journals/jlawp23 and id is 605 raw text is: 







          THE PROBLEMATICS OF THE BROWN-IS-
                  ORIGINALIST PROJECT

                          Ronald Turner*

    On May 17, 1954, the United States Supreme Court issued its
landmark decision in Brown v. Board of Education. Declaring
that in the field of public education the doctrine of 'separate but
equal' has no place,  the Court determined that we cannot turn
the clock back to 1868 when the Fourteenth Amendment was
adopted, or even to 1896 when Plessy v. Ferguson was written. 
Over the years, several originalist scholars have noted that an
interpretive theory that produces the conclusion that Brown was
wrongly decided will have little appeal, and have undertaken the
task of demonstrating that Brown can be squared with and justified
by originalism.
    This essay examines and critiques these efforts and focuses, in
particular, on one posited attribute and aspect of originalism: the
constraint on judges and interpreters. This essay argues that
certain originalist methodologies employed in the effort to justify
Brown are in fact discretionary in several key respects, and that
those answering in the affirmative is Brown originalist? have
employed discretionary originalism  in ways that are antithetical
to originalism's posited discretion-constraining promise.








*Alumnae Law Center Professor of Law, University of Houston Law Center.
J.D., University of Pennsylvania Law School; B.A., Wilberforce University. The
author acknowledges and is thankful for the research support provided by the
Alumnae Law Center donors and the University of Houston Law Foundation.