About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



11 IIUMLJ 263 (2003)
The 'Turnbull Guidelines' Proof and Evidence under the Malaysian Evidence Act 1950

handle is hein.journals/iiumlj11 and id is 266 raw text is: (2003) 11 IIUMLJ 263

THE 'TURNBULL GUIDELINES' PROOF AND
EVIDENCE UNDER THE MALAYSIAN EVIDENCE
ACT 1950
Abdul Rani Kamarudin
ABSTRACT
Turnbull guidelines is a requirement necessary as a
matter of law where the case against the accused
depended wholly or substantially on the correctness of
one or more identifications of the accused, which is
alleged by the defence to be mistaken identification.
There is a possibility that a mistaken witness can be a
convincing one and that a number of such witnesses
could all be mistaken. The Court has accepted that
evidence of identification is a category of evidence,
which though admissible, is thought to be unreliable
because of a risk of error The circumstances in which
the identification by each witness came to be made needs
to be examined. Though, recognition is thought to be
more reliable than identification, mistakes in recognition
of close relatives and friends are sometimes made. The
requirement is in the form of a warning (caution), and
provided that the caution is done in clear terms, the
judge need not use any particular form of words. The
quality of the identification evidence is what matters in
the end. A failure to follow the guidelines is likely to
Assistant Professor of Law, Ahmad Ibrahim Kulliyah of Laws,
International Islamic University, Malaysia.