About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



48 Cap. U. L. Rev. 487 (2020)
Labour Rights as Human Rights: The Derivation of Labour Rights from Civil and Political Rights under the European Convention on Human Rights

handle is hein.journals/capulr48 and id is 487 raw text is: 










            LABOUR RIGHTS AS HUMAN RIGHTS:
   THE   DERIVATION OF LABOUR RIGHTS FROM CIVIL
   AND POLITICAL RIGHTS UNDER THE EUROPEAN
              CONVENTION ON HUMAN RIGHTS
                           HUGH  COLLINS*



                    I.  DOWN   THE RABBIT-HOLE
    Today I would like to take you on a short trip to explore human rights
law in Europe. In principle, human rights have universal application, yet the
content and legal implications of those rights are susceptible to different
understandings. As Americans abroad in Europe, on this trip you will notice
striking and unfamiliar geographical features. When visiting Strasbourg, the
prospect reveals a court using international human rights law to protect
labour rights. Though largely absent in the United States and the United
Kingdom,  the practice of courts relying on human rights to protect workers'
interests has become a frequent occurrence in Europe.1 Indeed, following
the decline of the power of unions in recent decades, it might be claimed that
in Europe international human rights law has now become the most powerful
countervailing force available to workers to challenge the power of business
organizations and the economic forces of globalization.
    This recent legal development in Europe came as a surprise to many
scholars of labour law. Some labour rights such as freedom of association
or the right to strike are sometimes regarded as fundamental rights. They
are often enshrined in major pieces of national legislation such as the
National Labor Relations Act in the USA.2 Apart from  a few exceptions
such as freedom of association and the right to work, however, labour rights
are not usually listed in constitutional bills of rights.3 Nor are they listed in


   * Cassel Professor of Commercial Law, London School of Economics; Emeritus Vinerian
Professor of English Law, University of Oxford. This article was originally given as the 41st
John E. Sullivan Lecture, presented by Capital University Law School on October 29, 2019,
at the Ohio Statehouse.
   1 UNITED NATIONS HUMAN RIGHTS & INTER-PARLIAMENTARY UNION, HUMAN RIGHTS
HANDBOOK FOR PARLIAMENTARIANS N0 26 174-76, 187-91 (2016) [hereinafter HUMAN
RIGHTS HANDBOOK], hups://wwwvohchror2!DocumentsPubicationsHandbool-Parliamen
tariansjpdf [https://perma.cc/9RM7-RW8Q].
   2 29 U.S.C. § 157 (1935).
   3 See Otto Kahn-Freund, The Impact of Constitutions on Labour Law, 35 CAMBRIDGE L.J.
240, 258 (1976).