About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



10 Acta Univ. Sapientiae: Legal Stud. 161 (2021)
Can Justice Be Anything other than Human?

handle is hein.journals/ausapls10 and id is 164 raw text is: ACTA UNIV. SAPIENTIAE, LEGAL STUDIES, 10, 2 (2021) 161-168

DOI: 10.47745/AUSLEG.2021.10.2.01
Can Justice Be Anything Other than Human?
Emdd VERESS
PhD, University Professor
Sapientia Hungarian University of Transylvania (Cluj-Napoca, Romania)
Department of Law
Senior Research Fellow
Mddl Ferenc Institute of Comparative Law (Budapest, Hungary)
e-mail: emod.veress@sapientia.ro
Abstract. Artificial intelligence (AI) is an emerging technology in the field
of justice, which, though only used in limited fashion, is likely to bring
potentially disruptive changes in the future. This study examines some of
the most significant characteristics of AI that make it suited, and at the same
time unsuited, to application during litigation. Specifically, the problems of
opacity in decision making by machine learning algorithms and the lack of a
way to project flexible human morality on such systems is emphasized. The
author concludes that AI will be a useful tool for preparation of litigation;
however, it is less likely to replace the human judge, as adjudication
presupposes understanding of human sentiment and the sense of justice,
which requires some degree of bias in a positive sense.
Keywords: artificial intelligence, human factor, litigation, judge, machine
learning
One of the most significant suggestions made by those seeking to predict
the future is that artificial intelligence (AI) will be employed in the judiciary,
resulting in the replacement of some legal professions - as seems preferable by
some, mainly of lawyers - perhaps even of judges. One of the main proponents
of such views is Richard Susskind, who in his writings1 (The End of Lawyers?
or Tomorrow's Lawyers: An Introduction to Your Future) explores the potential
effects of artificial intelligence on legal professions.
This direction of development and its possible impact on legal services can
already be seen in Romania.2 The former president of the National Union of
Romanian Bar Associations made a particularly pessimistic statement3 about the
1   For a relevant review and critique, see Madocsai 2014.
2   Macovei 2018.
3   Florea 2017.