About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



30 Immigr. & Nat'lity L. Rev. 547 (2009)
In Democracy's Shadow: Fences, Raids, and the Production of Migrant Illegality

handle is hein.journals/inlr30 and id is 559 raw text is: ARTICLE
IN DEMOCRACY'S SHADOW: FENCES,
RAIDS, AND THE PRODUCTION OF
MIGRANT ILLEGALITY
Daniel Ibsen Morales*
ABSTRACT
Why is the United States building a border fence and raiding workplaces?
How has it come to harbor 12 million people without legal status? This article
proposes that we can understand these phenomena as the product of a legal culture
which privileges the desires and perspective of the citizenry over nearly every other
value. Accordingly, government is structured so that it approaches immigration in
a way that flatters this democratic epistemology, instead of acting on a judicious,
effective and humane policy perspective. Put into practice, this emphasis means
that immigration regulation is an exercise in symbolic action that harms illegal
migrants. We see the effects of this majoritarian architecture in the construction of
the border fence, which the Congressional Research Service has acknowledged
does little to control illegal immigration, but succeeds in increasing the rate of
migrant border deaths. Nevertheless, the fence prevails as policy because it
confirms and assuages the polity's fear of racial invasion; that it does little to
prevent undocumented migration means that the economy can continue to exploit
migrants labor.
This article also considers how the United States engages in these kinds of
actions and still maintains its outward image as liberty enlightening the world. 
* William H. Hastie Fellow, University of Wisconsin Law School, J.D., Yale Law School,
B.A., Williams College. For their patience, advice, and care, my deepest gratitude to Heinz
Klug and Michelle McKinley. Thanks also to Peter Carstensen, Jennifer Chac6n, Ruben
Garcia, Emesto Hemindez, Dale Ho, Osamudia James, Kathleen Kim, Angela Kupenda,
Jess McLeod, Hiroshi Motomura, John Ohnesorge, Hyuen Pham, Rick Su, Rose Cuison
Villazor and L. Darnell Weeden. This article is dedicated to my patient and supportive wife,
Gwen.
547
Originally published in 5 Stanford Journal of Civil Rights and Civil Liberties 23
(2009). Used by permission.