About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



11 Cardozo Pub. L. Pol'y & Ethics J. 385 (2012-2013)
Closing a Loophole in Musicians' Rights: Why Digital Remasters of Analog Sound Recordings Are Not Derivative Works Protected by the Copyright Act

handle is hein.journals/cardplp11 and id is 419 raw text is: CLOSING A LOOPHOLE IN MUSICIANS' RIGHTS:
WHY DIGITAL REMASTERS OF ANALOG SOUND
RECORDINGS ARE NOT DERIVATIVE WORKS
PROTECTED BY THE COPYRIGHT ACT
Jon Peritz*
INTRODUCTION     ..............................................  386
I. THE BACKDROP OF THE DEBATE ...................... 388
A. The Value and Protection of Master Recordings ....... 390
B.  D igital Remasters ..................................  391
C.   Termination  Rights ................................  392
D. The Issue of Works Made for Hire .................. 393
II. WHEN IS A DERIVATIVE WORK PROTECTED UNDER
C OPYRIGHT?   .........................................  400
A. Tests of Substantial and Distinguishable Variation .... 401
B. Protection of a Derivative Work Must Not Affect the
Scope of Protection in the Underlying Work .......... 406
C. Variation for Functional Considerations, Translations
to a New Medium, Artistic Skill and Hard Work do
not Constitute Substantial or Non- Trivial Variation .. 409
1. Variations from the Underlying Work Made for
Functional Considerations .................... 409
2. Works Created by Translating an Underlying
Work Into a New Medium ................... 410
3. Artistic Skill and Hard Work Do Not, In and
of Themselves, Constitute Sufficient Originality
to Warrant Protection ........................ 410
III. APPLICATION OF DERIVATIVE WORKS STANDARDS TO
DIGITALLY REMASTERED SOUND RECORDINGS ......... 412
A. Digitally Remastered Sound Recordings Do Not Vary
Substantially or Distinguishably from the Underlying
W ork  .............................................  4 12
Jon Peritz is a candidate for Juris Doctor at the Benjamin N. Cardozo School of Law
(May, 2013). Special thanks to Professors Justin Hughes and Brett Frischmann for their invalua-
ble input on this project and for teaching me about copyright law. Thanks also to my law school
colleagues whose encouragement was essential to getting this Note published. Thanks to the
editorial board and staffers of the Cardozo Public Law, Policy, and Ethics Journal for their
diligence and assistance. Finally, and most importantly, thanks to my incredible family and
friends for their unflagging support and love, without which I would not be who I am today.