About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



40 U. Haw. L. Rev. 209 (2017-2018)
Resolving the Legal Status of Dokdo/Takeshima: Why Join Referral to the International Court of Justice is a Realistic Approach

handle is hein.journals/uhawlr40 and id is 577 raw text is: 






             Resolving the Legal Status of

 Dokdo/Takeshima: Why Joint Referral to the

   International Court of Justice is a Realistic

                           Approach



                             Rio H. Kwon



I.   INTRODUCTION            ................................ ...... 209
II.  THE ROLE  OF  THE ICJ IN RESOLVING  TERRITORIAL   DISPUTES.  213
     A.  Introduction to the ICJ.     ...........................     ......... 213
     B.  Jurisdiction of the ICJfor Contentious Cases....................... 217
     C.  The ICJ has Resolved Several Controversial Territorial Disputes...... 219
III. BACKGROUND TO THE DISPUTE OVER DOKDO/TAKESHIMA .... 223
     A.  Korea Under Japanese Colonial Rule......................... 223
     B.  The Law of Territorial Sovereignty..        ......................... 225
     C.  South Korea's Claims to Dokdo/Takeshima         .................... 225
     D.  Japan's Claims to Dokdo/Takeshima       ...................   ...... 230
IV.  THE ICJ IS LIKELY TO RULE  IN FAVOR  OF  SOUTH  KOREA.......... 234
V.   CONCLUSION...................................           ..... 243



                      I.      INTRODUCTION

  The old nationalist tensions are rising over some disputed Asian islands.

  This  statement aptly characterizes the current dispute between South
Korea2 and  Japan over some  disputed Asian islands.3           These islands,
which have a land area of just 187,554 M2 ,4 are known as Dokdo in South



   * J.D. Candidate, William S. Richardson School of Law, University of Hawai'i at

Manoa, class of 2018.
   1 Sheila A. Smith, Why Japan, South Korea, and China are so Riled Up Over a Few
Tiny        Islands,      ATLANTIC       (Aug.        16,       2012),
https://www.theatlantic.com/international/archive/2012/08/why-japan-south-korea-and-
china-are-so-riled-up-over-a-few-tiny-islands/261224/.
   2 For purposes of clarity, this paper will use the names South Korea and North
Korea accordingly. In addition, Korea and the names of various States that preceded the
modern Korean nation will be used accordingly.
   3 Smith, supra note 1.
   4 Jon M. Van Dyke, Legal Issues Related to Sovereignty over Dokdo and its Maritime
Boundary, 38 OCEAN DEv. & INT'L L. 157, 157 (2007) [hereinafter Van Dyke, Legal Issues
Related to Dokdol.