About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



74 Tenn. L. Rev. 259 (2006-2007)
Constitutional Law - Search and Seizure - Validity of Consent to Warrantless Search of Residence When Co-Occupant Expressly Objects

handle is hein.journals/tenn74 and id is 267 raw text is: CONSTITUTIONAL LAW-SEARCH AND SEIZURE-
VALIDITY OF CONSENT TO WARRANTLESS
SEARCH OF RESIDENCE WHEN CO-OCCUPANT
EXPRESSLY OBJECTS
Georgia v. Randolph, 126 S. Ct. 1515 (2006).
I. INTRODUCTION
On July 6, 2001, after police officers responded to a call from defendant
Scott Randolph's estranged wife, she volunteered that the defendant was a
cocaine user and that the officers could find evidence of his drug use in the
house.' One of the officers asked the defendant for permission to search the
house, but he expressly refused.2 The officer then asked the defendant's wife
for her permission, and she consented. She led the officer to a bedroom which
she identified as the defendant's, where the officer saw a section of a drinking
straw with a powdery residue on it.4 The officer left the house to obtain an
evidence bag and call the district attorney's office, which immediately
instructed him to cease the search and apply for a warrant.5 Later, the police
returned with a warrant and seized additional evidence of drug use. On this
basis, the defendant was indicted for possession of cocaine.6 He moved to
suppress the evidence, claiming that it was obtained through a warrantless
search that could not have been authorized by his wife's consent because he
7
had already unequivocally refused the search. The trial court denied his
motion, ruling that his wife had common authority to consent to the search.8
1. Georgiav. Randolph, 126 S. Ct. 1515, 1519(2006). The defendant and his wife had
separated in May 2001. Id. The defendant's wife and son had recently returned to the
defendant's home after living with family members in Canada for several weeks. Id. The
officers had come to the house on July 6 because the defendant's wife had reported that the
defendant had taken their son away following a domestic dispute. Id. The defendant returned to
the house while the officers were there, explaining that he had taken the child to a neighbor's
house to prevent his wife from taking their son out of the country again. Id. He also claimed
that he did not use cocaine and that, in fact, his wife abused drugs and alcohol. Id.
2. Id.
3. Id.
4. Id.
5. Id. When the officer returned to the house after placing the phone call, the
defendant's wife withdrew her consent to the search. Id. The officers then took the piece of
straw and the Randolphs to the police station. Id.
6. Id.
7. Id.
8. Id.