About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



24 J. Marshall L. Rev. 263 (1990-1991)
The Elimination of Process: Will the Biotechnology Patent Protection Act Revive Process Patents

handle is hein.journals/jmlr24 and id is 277 raw text is: COMMENT
THE ELIMINATION OF PROCESS: WILL THE
BIOTECHNOLOGY PATENT PROTECTION
ACT REVIVE PROCESS PATENTS?
I. INTRODUCTION
With the encouragement of George Washington and Thomas
Jefferson, Congress enacted the first patent act on April 19, 1790.1
For two hundred years the patent system has been an important
means of encouraging the advancement of the sciences.2 However,
due in part to the success of the patent laws in achieving this end,
new technologies have emerged that may not fit into the patent
code. One of these is biotechnology.
1. H. TOULMIN, JR., INVENTION & THE LAw 10-11 (1936). On July 31 of the
same year, the Commission for the Promotion of Useful Arts issued its first
patent to Samuel Hopkins of Vermont for a process of making potash and pearl
ash. Secretary of State Thomas Jefferson, an inventor himself, together with
the Secretary of the Department of War and the Attorney General, formed the
Commission. Graham v. John Deere Co., 383 U.S. 1, 6-7 (1966). Any two of
these individuals could issue a patent. Id. at 7. Eventually, this function be-
came too burdensome in combination with the officers' other duties, and the
judiciary assumed the responsibility of issuing patents. Id. at 10.
2. Mr. Toulmin praises the United States' enlightened patent system for
paving the road to America's success in industry. H. TOULMIN, JR., HANDBOOK
OF PATENTS 4 (1949). Toulmin agreed with Abraham Lincoln, recipient of U.S.
Patent No. 6,649 for 'A Device for Buoying Vessels over Shoals,' who said, The
patent system added the fuel of interest to the fire of genius. Id. at 31 n.39, iii.
A solid patent system is a highly significant component of technological ad-
vancement. Adler, Biotechnology Development and Transfer: Recommenda-
tions for an Integrated Policy, 11 RUTGERS COMPUTER & TECH. L.J. 464, 478
(1985). Whether respondent's claims are patentable may determine whether
research efforts are accelerated by the hope of reward or slowed by want of
incentives .... Diamond v. Chakrabarty, 447 U.S. 303, 317 (1980); see generally
C. JuMA, THE GENE HUNTERS: BIOTECHNOLOGY AND THE SCRAMBLE FOR SEEDS,
149-78 (1989) (analyzing effect of intellectual property protection on plant tech-
nology advancement).
But see Buttel & Belsky, Biotechnology, Plant Breeding, and Intellectual
Property: Social and Ethical Dimensions, 12 SCIENCE TECH. & HUMAN VALUES
31 (1987). In their study of the seed industry, Buttel and Belsky concluded that
while the Patent Act was effective in sparking economic growth (which led to
the formation of U.S. and multinational seed companies), it was less effective in
stimulating research and formation of new seed varieties. Id. at 35. Rather, the
major companies actively discouraged the release of new varieties, which would
mean increased competition. Id.