About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



63 Fed. Probation 51 (1999)
The Strengths Perspective: A Paradigm for Correctional Counseling

handle is hein.journals/fedpro63 and id is 59 raw text is: The Strengths Perspective: A Paradigm
for Correctional Counseling
BY KATHERINE VAN WORMER, PH.D.
Professor, Department of Social Work, University of Northern Iowa
In every child who is born, under no matter what circumstances, and of no matter what parents, the potentiality of the human race is born again.
-James Agee

AdT THE heart of the strengths perspective is a belief in
.the basic goodness of humankind, a faith that indi-
iduals, however unfortunate their plight, can dis-
cover strengths in themselves that they never knew existed.
No matter how little or how much may be expressed at one
time, as Weick, Rapp, Sullivan, and Kisthardt (1989) explain,
people often have a potential that is not commonly realized.
The Biblical injunction from Matthew 7:7 sums it up in a
nutshell: Seek and ye shall find. This cardinal principle is
implied in the opening statement of the social work Code of
Ethics: Social workers' primary responsibility is to pro-
mote the well-being of clients (National Association of
Social Workers, 1996, p. 1.01). The first step in promoting
the client's well-being is through assessing the client's
strengths. A belief in human potential is tied to the notion
that people have untapped resources-physically, emotion-
ally, socially, and spiritually-that they can mobilize in
times of need. This is where professional helping comes
into play-in tapping into the possibilities, into what can be,
not what is.
The view of humanity underlying the strengths approach
is that humans are unique and multifaceted beings (Kelley,
1996). In clinical settings, however, simple labels based on
pathology, often highly pejorative in connotation, tend to
take on a life of their own. Clients come to be seen as uni-
dimensional, their very being tailor-made to the therapist's
special needs. Years ago, Dennis Wrong (1976, p. 112) chid-
ed social scientists for this very flaw: We must do better,
he wrote, if we really wish to win credit outside our ranks
for special understanding of man, that plausible creature
whose wagging tongue so often hides the despair and dark-
ness in his heart. His words are especially relevant to the
treatment process, a process where the search for root
causes of problems often blinds us to underlying strengths.
Deficit, disease, and dysfunction metaphors permeate
treatment at every stage of the process, from intake to termi-
nation (Cowger, 1994). In the criminal justice system, clients
often find their very selfhood defined by their crimes. For
such persons, whose views of therapy and of all authority fig-
ures are apt to be decidedly negative, a positive approach is
essential to establish the one crucial ingredient of effective
treatment-trust. Sometimes one encounter or one support-
ive relationship-whether with a teacher, social worker, or
priest-can offer a turning point in a life of crime.
Who can forget the thief Jean Valjean's about-face in Victor
Hugo's Les Miserables, when the kind priest, the victim, tells

the police that the stolen candelabras were not stolen but a
gift from himself? Or even the cold-blooded killer in the film
Dead Man Walking, who grows personally and, to some
extent, spiritually through his relationship with a caring nun.
These two examples--one fictional, one based on fact-illu-
minate a theme of personal empowerment. One of the major
tasks of the professional helper is to facilitate such change.
Within the justice context, the challenge consists of promot-
ing personal power in people whose lives have become cir-
cumscribed to varying degrees and whose very existence has
been devalued and even criminalized.
A second major challenge to correctional social work is
the challenge of viewing causality reciprocally. With crini-
nal behavior, the locus of the problem is not the individual
alone but the individual and society in interaction. To study
the person-in-the-environment is not enough; one also
needs to study the environment-in-the-person. If we con-
ceive of the environment as the prison, we can view the new
recruits as bringing into this milieu all of what Irwin (1980)
calls the cultural baggage from their social background.
And then we can view aspects of prison life-the social con-
trol, the convict norms-as internalized within the prison
inmate. Both the person and the environment can be seen to
be in continuous and dynamic interaction in this way. If we
come to frame the inmates' confinement in a political sense,
then we have moved toward a linking of the personal and
political levels of existence (Lee, 1994).
More than any other population, correctional clients are
the failures of the failures. Not only have they publicly been
labeled through some kind of court action, but their
encounter with professional counselors usually relates to
some kind of punishment. Work in the correctional realm,
then, with all the negatives stacked against it, is an excellent
testing ground for a framework of strengths. In contrast to
a diagnostic, pathology-based therapy, direct practice from
this multidimensional framework looks beyond a client's
diagnosis or offense-for example, borderline personality
or drug possession-to positive attributes that can serve as
an important resource even in the most desperate of cir-
cumstances. The challenge of the present article is to dis-
cover to what extent an approach that is geared toward
individual resourcefulness and health is relevant for those
who have been identified by society as criminal. To put this
more graphically, the challenge is to discover if an
approach, a model, that is successful in helping battered
women suffering from low self-esteem also would be effec-

Vol. 63, No. 1