About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



47 Colum. J. Transnat'l L. 292 (2008-2009)
Human Shields in International Humanitarian Law

handle is hein.journals/cjtl47 and id is 298 raw text is: Human Shields in International Humanitarian
Law
MICHAEL N. SCHMITT*
This article explores the international humanitarian
law governing the use of human shields, a tragically
prevalent tactic in contemporary warfare. It begins
by setting forth the express prohibitions on the use of
human shields. These prohibitions are uncontrover-
sial and generally accepted as reflective of customary
international law. Much more problematic is the is-
sue of how the use of human shields affects an at-
tacker's obligations under international humanitarian
law. No treaty norm addresses the issue. This article
distinguishes between compelled and voluntary shield-
ing. It argues that those compelled to shield retain all
the protections to which they are entitled as civilians
during an attack. This result remains true despite the
clear violation of international humanitarian law by
the attacker's enemy. By contrast, those who volun-
tarily shield a military objective qualify as direct
participants in hostilities.  As such, international
humanitarian law removes their immunity from attack
during the period of participation. Although there
will seldom be a military reason to target voluntary
shields,  their  status  as   direct  participants
does influence battlefield application of both the pro-
portionality rule (prohibiting attacks expected to
cause excessive collateral damage) and the legal re-
quirement to take feasible precautions in attack (re-
quiring attackers to take steps to minimize harm to ci-
vilians). This article concludes by suggesting that in
* Charles H. Stockton Visiting Professor of International Law, United States Naval
War College; Dean and Professor of International Law, George C. Marshall European Cen-
ter for Security Studies, Garmisch-Partenkirchen, Germany.