About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



2020 AJICJ 151 (2020)
Asian Perspectives on the International Law Commission's Work on Crimes against Humanity

handle is hein.journals/ajicj2020 and id is 157 raw text is: 






Asian Perspectives on the International Law

Commission's Work on Crimes Against

Humanity

Mari Takeuchi'


Abstract

    No Asian States expressed regret over the failure of the Sixth Committee to reach a
    consensus on the elaboration of a convention on crimes against humanity. This art-
    icle examines the comments of Asian States during the Sixth Committee debate on
    the final Draft Articles submitted by the International Law Commission, demon-
    strating that most States believed further discussions were needed. It situates
    these comments against the wider Asian approach to international criminal law,
    and argues that the concerns of the Asian States during the Sixth Committee are
    part of a broader context. In doing so, it suggests a common ground for future dis-
    cussion and the progression of a convention.


Keywords:   Asian States, crimes against humanity, international criminal law,
Draft Articles on Prevention and Punishment of Crimes Against Humanity.


1   Introduction

In its seventy-first session in 2019, the International Law Commission (ILC) com-
pleted the second reading of its Draft Articles on Prevention and Punishment of
Crimes Against Humanity  and submitted it to the General Assembly with a rec-
ommendation   that States elaborate a convention  under the auspices of the
United Nations  or by an international conference of plenipotentiaries on the
basis of the Draft Articles. However, the Sixth Committee was unable to agree on
an elaboration of a convention as recommended by the ILC. The statement of the
Singapore delegation, which introduced the draft resolution on crimes against
humanity  at the end of the Sixth Committee debate, urged delegations to con-
tinue to genuinely seek to understand the view of others and work together to
find mutually acceptable solutions.' This indicates that there was some division
on how to proceed with the Draft Articles.
    In seeking a way to accommodate differing views among States on a way for-
ward, it seems crucial to examine opinions of Asian States. Indeed, there was no
Asian State among those 43 States expressing regret over the failure of the Sixth
Committee  to reach a consensus on an elaboration of a convention. In fact, as will

*   Professor of International Law, Kobe University, Graduate School of Law, Japan.
1   A/C.6/74/SR.35 (2019), Para. 31.


African Journal of International Criminal Justice 2020 (6) 2             151
doi: 10.5553/AJ/2352068X2020006002006